O.K we're currently judging the best and worst celebs on another strand. Please keep those votes coming in. But let's have a look at the Pro dancers

To qualify, they must have competed in at least two series of SCD.

Here's the list.

Men
Darren Bennett
Brendan Cole
Anton Du Beke
Paul Killick
Ian Waite

Women
Erin Boag
Nicole Cutler
Camilla Dallerup
Karen Hardy
Lilia Kopylova

It's five points for the best, down to one point

Brendan Cole - 5
Darren Bennett - 4
Paul Killick - 3
Ian Waite - 2
Anton Du Beke - 1

Love all of the equally

Lilia Kopylova - 5
Karen Hardy - 4
Camilla dallerup - 3
Nicole Cutler - 2
Erin Boag - 1

Darren Bennett - 5
Paul Killick - 4
Anton Du Beke - 3
Brendon Cole - 2
Ian Waite - 1

Lilia Kopylova - 5
Erin Boag - 4
Nicole Culter - 3
Camilla Dallerup - 2
Karen Hardy - 1

Looking at the votes at present, I'm guessing you must mean 'favourite' rather than 'best', am I right?

No not at all everyones opinions are different therefore they are going to put who they think are the best at the top of the poll

You obviously disagree with what some people have polled so do your own list and stop making a fuss!

Can someone please tell me where Matt Cutler is....well not literally I mean on the list.......!

Women:
Karen Hardy 5
Nicole Cutler 4
Erin Boag 3
Camilla Dallerup 2
Lilia Kopylova 1

Men:
Paul Killick 5
Brendan Cole 4
Ian Waite 3
Anton Du Beke 2
Darren Bennett 1
Last edited by lhme65 : 15-02-2007 at 20:26

Men
Darren Bennett- 5
Brendan Cole- 2
Anton Du Beke- 1
Paul Killick- 4
Ian Waite- 3

Women
Erin Boag- 2
Nicole Cutler- 3
Camilla Dallerup- 4
Karen Hardy- 1
Lilia Kopylova- 5

I must agree that Mr Cutler should be there! Thats just my opinion it may differ to other people's of course.

Not sure about everyone else but I chose best as opposed to favourite.

Not sure how you arrived at 1 point for Lilia and Darren when they have both produced winning celebs

I'm not basing my opinion on who has produced winning celebrities (which would be about ranking who I think is the best teacher). I'm basing it on my perception of their dancing ability... where Karen Hardy, the Cutlers and Paul Killick are quite a way in front (IMO only of course). The rest I would actually rank pretty much equal with each other with respect to dancing ability, so I just went with who I personally like. I genuinely like Lilia. I just like Erin and Camilla more. With Darren, I'm really just not a fan. Karen has been given only one point by a couple of people and she's produced a winner too. It's just a personal opinion.
Last edited by lhme65 : 15-02-2007 at 21:10

Men
Darren Bennett- 4
Brendan Cole- 5
Anton Du Beke- 2
Paul Killick- 1
Ian Waite- 3

Women
Erin Boag- 1
Nicole Cutler- 1
Camilla Dallerup- 3
Karen Hardy- 5
Lilia Kopylova- 4

Anton du Beke 5
Darren Bennett 4
Paul killick 3
Ian Waite 2
Brendan Cole 1

Erin Boag 5
Nicole Cutler 4
Lilia Kopylova 3
Karen Hardy 2
Camilla Dallerup 1

Women:
Karen Hardy 5
Nicole Cutler 2
Erin Boag 4
Camilla Dallerup 1
Lilia Kopylova 3

Men:
Paul Killick 3
Brendan Cole 4
Ian Waite 5
Anton Du Beke 2
Darren Bennett 1

Why then isn't Matt on the list?!?
Last edited by princess_katy : 15-02-2007 at 21:15

Darren Bennett - 5
Brendan Cole - 4
Anton du Beke - 3
Ian Waite - 2
Paul Killick - 1

Karen - 5
Lilia - 4
Nicole - 3
Camillia - 2
Erin - 1

Women:
Karen Hardy 4
Nicole Cutler1
Erin Boag 3
Camilla Dallerup 2
Lilia Kopylova 5

Men:
Paul Killick 1
Brendan Cole 5
Ian Waite 2
Anton Du Beke 4
Darren Bennett 3

Ask the OP were only voting on who we've been given

I have no idea...lol. He'd get 5 points from me anyway if he was an option.

Matt would score high with me too

Did I once say that I disagreed? NO.

I am asking a perfectly reasonable question, as I did not understand how I was being expected to respond to the original question. MAKING A FUSS? HA! No ta, just making a general query.

I don't understand how people on this forum can turn from having perfectly nice topic to being nasty, upsetting people, making silly accusations and aiming to get peoples' backs up!

Can't we all just be nice?
Last edited by * Becca * : 15-02-2007 at 22:03

Men
Erin boag- 5
Lilia kopylova -4
Karen hardy- 3
Camilla dallerup - 2
Nicole cutler - 1

Men
Darren benett- 5
Anton du beke- 4
Brendan Cole- 3
Ian waite -2
Paul killick - 1

I put erin at the top as i think if her and anton went back to compeating they would be good and i also think erins latin is fab and well antons isn't so thats why he's at 4

Men
Darren Bennett:3
Brendan Cole:2
Anton Du Beke:4
Paul Killick:1
Ian Waite:5

Women
Erin Boag:1
Nicole Cutler:2
Camilla Dallerup:4
Karen Hardy:5
Lilia Kopylova:3

Women
Nicole Cutler - 5
Lilia Kopylova - 5 (love them equally so they're joint top for me)
Erin Boag - 3
Camilla - 3
Karen - 1



Men
Darren benett- 5
Matt Cutler - 5 (sorry, so adding him in....he tottaly deserves to be there!! - and also joint equally with darren!!)
Paul Killick - 3
Brendan - 2
Ian - 1

Not participating because Matthew Cutler is missing off the original list.

(Sorry Princess Katy, I can see you tried)