Tara's singing voice was on a par with Miranda!
Last edited by cute chick : 16-03-2007 at 21:27

I really liked Tara's singing and her singing voice

The best person won.

As I've just said on an almost duplicate thread...

I suspect Tara won for the same reason that (sorry about this) mediocre talent often tends to win through - we all deep down think "hmm, I could do that!".

Not without the connections you can't!

That having been said I am pleased for her and I really enjoyed watching her and I cared so little about who won that I didn't even watch the final tonight but just came on here to check it out! I would slightly have preferred Tricia to win though, simply because she's so much better vocally and no other reason.

I carefully watched the student vote and all the boys voted for Shaun and all the girls voted for Tricia - if there had been one more boy instead of one more girl then Shaun would have been in the final - just shows that the boys stick together as much as the girls.

Who won?
edit: nevermind I just read through the thread
Last edited by x Sparkie x : 17-03-2007 at 11:48

Nonsense it's not X factor it's comic relief and the winner should be the one who provided us with good entertainment value which Tara wins with hands down.

I was shocked when Tara got through to the final
at the expense of Shaun
As for her winning the thing surely its a joke (Comic Relief)

You cannot assume that the additional boy would have followed the same voting pattern though.