who do u think should have been botom 3 this week

personally

it would be gina stephanie and sanjaya

Stephanie
Phil
Chris S

Gina
Stephanie
Sanjaya

Thought Chris Sligh gave the best male vocal this week

Jordin was the best overall though for me.

Was puzzled as to why they only announced a bottom 2 though

^ Yeah, and they didn't have a group song or the booted contestant sing again? Guess they were pushed for time.

Do you remember last season they experimented with having the Bottom 2 both sing again, ala X Factor?

I think the bottom 3 should have been Chris R, Stephanie and Sanjaya. Since 2 out of 3 were there I think this week was a fair result.

for me the weakest were:
stephanie, sanjaya, gina
Phil was also very poor (and he scares me anyway) and i was disappointed in Chris Sligh.

And actually, while we're on the subject - did anyone else think Lakisha was way too copycat on her Bassey number?? mannerisms and everything. Plus, I felt Melinda is playing way too safe.

Jordin and Blake stood out for me (but i don't like his crazy golf fashion), with Chris R close behind. Nice to see Haley do well - there's a bit of fighting spirit she needed to show.

alot of people in agreement then

i like lakisha i dont know how else she could have done that song

Haley & Sanjaya should've been bottom two
with the third being either Phil, Chris R, Blake or Gina
(I'm so gutted Stephanie left!)

Gina, Haley & Phil

Stephanie shouldn't have gone, she's a class act

[quote=SteveOwen]^ Yeah, and they didn't have a group song or the booted contestant sing again? Guess they were pushed for time.

They had to find the time for the two has-beens to sing

Bottom 3 for me were

Gina
Steph
Sanjaya

but since Sanjaya gave his best performance to date, he was never going to go out this week. Steph however has been below par for the past few weeks and this week's performance was just the nail in the coffin even though she deserved to make the Top 10 and the tour.

they always seem pushed for time on our show

my friend in america says they show alot more

Bottom 3 should have been Sanjaya, Phil & Gina based on performance alone.

Sanjay, Gina and Steph