Judoon +2
The Beast -5

35 Daleks
25 Judoon
23 Clockwork Robots
16 Cybermen
10 The Beast
9 Gelth
6 Krillitanes
2 Plasmavore

Clockwork Robots +2
Krillitanes -2
Plasmavore -2
Judoon -1

35 Daleks
25 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
16 Cybermen
10 The Beast
9 Gelth
4 Krillitanes

(Plasmavore eliminated)
Last edited by Histeria : 07-04-2007 at 16:01

So much for being a survivor at all costs...

Is anybody else as surprised as me at the strong showing by the Clockwork Robots? I thought they were great, but they did suffer from Slow Villain Syndrome, which was the only bad moment of that episode. Still, on with the show! Bo-sho-no-kro-lo-mro-bo-ro.

+2 judoon , - 4 krillitanes , -1 the beast


35 Daleks
26 Judoon
25 Clockwork Robots
16 Cybermen
9 The Beast
9 Gelth

Krillitanes emliminated

Missed the first part - oh well...

+2 The Beast , - 5 Cybermen


35 Daleks
26 Judoon
25 Clockwork Robots
11 The Beast
11 Cybermen
9 Gelth

Krillitanes emliminated

The Beast is probably the only enemy so far that's shown real vision and cinematic presence. Hope we get to see it again this finalé. The Cybermen has been the biggest disappointment in that list.

2 Clockwork Robots
- 5 The Gelth


35 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
26 Judoon
11 The Beast
11 Cybermen
4 Gelth

In regards to the clockwork robots, they seem like very old school who and they looked really good.

I'm quite surprised by the cybermen doing so badly. I thought they were quite disturbing in Age of Steel.

Bring on Round 3!

+ 2 Gelth
-1 Cybermen
- 2 Beast
-2 Judoon

35 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
10 Cybermen
9 The Beast
6 Gelth

I loved them - slow but seriously creepy.

-4 Cybermen
+3 Gelth

35 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
9 The Beast
9 Gelth
6 Cybermen

+2 The Beast - Loved the whole concept - hope to see more

-2 Daleks
-3 Cybermen - Both losing points for the "campy banter" in the series finale. Ooooh how menacing :yawn:


33 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
11 The Beast
9 Gelth
3 Cybermen

-3 Cybermen
+2 Gelth
+2 Beast

33 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
13 The Beast
11 Gelth
0 Cybermen - Eliminated

Doesn't Mitch have to vote again, as it should have been minus 5 and plus 2 rather than minus 3 and plus 4.

Does this mean that I can go to the post above Mitch and add my vote and get it back on course?

Only asking this as I want to vote for the Cybermen.

Mitch has been very naughty, in round 2 he has taken 7 points from the Cybermen and given 5 to the Gelth and 2 to the Beast.

It will be up to PaperOstrich to umpire on this one.

My suggestion is that Mitch's first vote should be amended in the way that seems to best reflect his views, ie Cybermen -5 and Gelth + 2, then his second vote should be discounted.

The amended scores would then be:

33 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
11 The Beast
8 Gelth
2 Cybermen

Can I humbly recommend that until the Ostrich gives a definitive ruling we carry on from this position?

28 Daleks
28 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
12 The Beast
8 Gelth
2 Cybermen

Daleks -5, Clockwork Robots +1, The ?beast +1

31 Daleks
25 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
12 The Beast
8 Gelth
2 Cybermen

Daleks +3
Clockwork Robots -3 (terrible from moffat how could they compare to the daleks!)
Could someone please eliminate the gelth because ive used all my points!

I'm going to take one off Daleks cos last poster added 3 rather than 2.

I'm also going to give take 2 from cybermen, 3 from daleks and give 2 to the clockwork robots

27 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
12 The Beast
8 Gelth
0 Cybermen (Delete!)

CURRENT SCORES -

27 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
12 The Beast
8 Gelth


Oooh will the Clockwork Robots become the favourite of the New Series?

BTW Do the Nanogenes count as villains?

You had 2 points to give and 5 to take in this round, so I'll take 2 off the Gelth for you (your extra point for the Daleks has already been dealt with)...

27 Daleks
27 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
12 The Beast
6 Gelth

+2 Daleks
-3 Clockwork Robots
-2 the beast

29 Daleks
24 Clockwork Robots
24 Judoon
10 The Beast
8 Gelth

-5 Clockwork Robots
+1 Daleks
+1 Judoon

30 Daleks
25 Judoon
19 Clockwork Robots
10 The Beast
8 Gelth

30 Daleks
26 Judoon
20 Clockwork Robots
10 The Beast
3 Gelth

1+ Judoon
1+ Clockwork Robots
5- Gelth

oops sorry didnt read this rounds rules... :yawn:

26 Judoon
25 Daleks
20 Clockwork Robots
10 The Beast
5 Gelth

-5 Daleks
+2 Gelth

Mitch, youve already voted (and cocked it up twice), so we'll ignore yours (sorry if i'm stamping some authority). The last proper vote was Stick of Rock with:

30 Daleks
26 Judoon
20 Clockwork Robots
10 The Beast
3 Gelth

32 Daleks
24 Judoon
19 Clockwork Robots
9 The Beast
2 Gelth