• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Doctor Who Episode Elimination Season
<<
<
3 of 4
>>
>
david@payne01.f
19-04-2007
surely there was an easier way of doing this like rate out on a scale of 1 to 13 in order of preference, or start each on zero and ask people to add 3 points to their favourite episode(s), cause this is going so slow.
LlamaKing
19-04-2007
Season 1
The Unquiet Dead 5 (-3)
Dalek 17
Father's Day 16 (+3)
The Empty Child 42
The Doctor Dances 24
Bad Wolf 4
The Parting of the Ways 20

Season 2
Tooth and Claw 5 (-3)
School Reunion 11 (+3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 32
The Impossible Planet 24
The Satan Pit 25
Army of Ghosts 9
Doomsday 21

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
The Slug
19-04-2007
Originally Posted by david@payne01.f:
“surely there was an easier way of doing this like rate out on a scale of 1 to 13 in order of preference, or start each on zero and ask people to add 3 points to their favourite episode(s), cause this is going so slow.”

Go and watch some of the classic series, then come back and tell us this is too slow!
Muttley76
19-04-2007
Season 1
The Unquiet Dead 4 (-1)
Dalek 16 (-1)
Father's Day 16
The Empty Child 43 (+1)
The Doctor Dances 25 (+1)
Bad Wolf 3 (-1)
The Parting of the Ways 21 (+1)

Season 2
Tooth and Claw 4 (-1)
School Reunion 12 (+1)
The Girl in the Fireplace 31 (-1)
The Impossible Planet 24
The Satan Pit 26 (+1)
Army of Ghosts 8 (-1)
Doomsday 22 (+1)

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
garbage456
20-04-2007
Originally Posted by The Slug:
“Go and watch some of the classic series, then come back and tell us this is too slow! ”

Yes it is slow but I agree with the original post it could of been done differently
garbage456
20-04-2007
Season 1
The Unquiet Dead 7 (+3)
Dalek 13 (-3)
Father's Day 16
The Empty Child 43
The Doctor Dances 25
Bad Wolf 3
The Parting of the Ways 21

Season 2
Tooth and Claw 4
School Reunion 15 (+3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 28 (-3)
The Impossible Planet 24
The Satan Pit 26
Army of Ghosts 8
Doomsday 22

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Telcontar
20-04-2007
Season 1
The Unquiet Dead 7
Dalek 14 (+1)
Father's Day 16
The Empty Child 44 (+1)
The Doctor Dances 25
Bad Wolf 0 (-3) Eliminated
The Parting of the Ways 22 (+1)

Season 2
Tooth and Claw 4
School Reunion 14 (-1)
The Girl in the Fireplace 29 (+1)
The Impossible Planet 25 (+1)
The Satan Pit 27 (+1)
Army of Ghosts 6 (-2)
Doomsday 22

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
asto47
20-04-2007
Season 1
The Unquiet Dead 4 (-3)
Dalek 15 (+1)
Father's Day 17 (+1)
The Empty Child 44
The Doctor Dances 26 (+1)
The Parting of the Ways 22

Season 2
Tooth and Claw 5 (+1)
School Reunion 14
The Girl in the Fireplace 30 (+1)
The Impossible Planet 25
The Satan Pit 24 (-3)
Army of Ghosts 6
Doomsday 23 (+1)

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
priggy
20-04-2007
Season 1
The Unquiet Dead 2 (-2)
Dalek 16 (+1)
Father's Day 16 (-1)
The Empty Child 44
The Doctor Dances 27 (+1)
The Parting of the Ways 23 (+1)

Season 2
Tooth and Claw 3 (-2)
School Reunion 17 (+3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 30
The Impossible Planet 25
The Satan Pit 24
Army of Ghosts 5 (-1)
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
TailsFox
20-04-2007
Season 1
Dalek 16
Father's Day 16
The Empty Child 44
The Doctor Dances 27
The Parting of the Ways 23

Season 2
Tooth and Claw 2 (-1)
School Reunion 20 (+3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 30
The Impossible Planet 25
The Satan Pit 24
Army of Ghosts 5
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead 0 (-2) Eliminated (S1)
Silent Timelord
21-04-2007
Season 1
Dalek 19 (+3)
Father's Day 13 (-3)
The Empty Child 44
The Doctor Dances 27
The Parting of the Ways 23

Season 2
School Reunion 20
The Girl in the Fireplace 29 (-1)
The Impossible Planet 25
The Satan Pit 27 (+3)
Army of Ghosts 5
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead(S1)
Tooth and Claw (-2) (S2)
RoughlyUnderage
21-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 10 (-3)
The Empty Child 47 (+3)
The Doctor Dances 27
The Parting of the Ways 23


Season 2

School Reunion 17 (-3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 29
The Impossible Planet 28 (+3)
The Satan Pit 27
Army of Ghosts 5
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
Muttley76
21-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 17 (-2)
Father's Day 9 (-1)
The Empty Child 48 (+1)
The Doctor Dances 28 (+1)
The Parting of the Ways 24 (+1)


Season 2

School Reunion 18 (+1)
The Girl in the Fireplace 27 (-2)
The Impossible Planet 28
The Satan Pit 28 (+1)
Army of Ghosts 4 (-1)
Doomsday 24 (+1)

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)[/quote]
priggy
21-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 7 (-3)
The Empty Child 47
The Doctor Dances 30 (+3)
The Parting of the Ways 23


Season 2

School Reunion 17
The Girl in the Fireplace 29
The Impossible Planet 28
The Satan Pit 30 (+3)
Army of Ghosts 2 (-3)
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
TailsFox
21-04-2007
I think that mcgee007 should pull a close to this elimination thread now because there is no way any of these top ones are going to be eliminated now is there. This is how the episode elimination should stand if you close it now.

1st The Empty Child 48 (S1)
2nd The Impossible Planet 28 (S2)
2nd The Doctor Dances 28 (S1)
2nd The Satan Pit 28 (S2)
3rd The Girl In The Fireplace 27 (S2)
4th The Parting Of Ways (S2)
4th Doomsday 24 (S2)
5th School Reunion 18 (S2)
6th Dalek 17 (S1)
7th Father's Day 9 (S1)
8th Army Of Ghosts 4 (S2)
9th Tooth & Claw (Eliminated) (S2)
10th The Unquiet Dead (Eliminated) (S1)

That looks like the top ten BUT I can't close this thread so mcgee007 - you can do that!
garbage456
21-04-2007
Originally Posted by RoughlyUnderage:
“Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 10 (-3)
The Empty Child 47 (+3)
The Doctor Dances 27
The Parting of the Ways 23


Season 2

School Reunion 17 (-3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 29
The Impossible Planet 28 (+3)
The Satan Pit 27
Army of Ghosts 5
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:
World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)”

i thought we was only aloud to vote once, you have done 3 now, have i misread the rules, if so can I do my remaining 2 goes now?
Last edited by garbage456 : 21-04-2007 at 16:20
garbage456
21-04-2007
Originally Posted by priggy:
“Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 7
The Empty Child 53 (+6)
The Doctor Dances 30
The Parting of the Ways 23


Season 2

School Reunion 23 (+6)
The Girl in the Fireplace 23 (-6)
The Impossible Planet 28
The Satan Pit 30
Army of Ghosts 2
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)”

if so mine would be as above now
Telcontar
21-04-2007
garbage456: These are the rules stated in the original post.

Originally Posted by mcgee007:
“Hi all, welcome to the elimination thread! In Round one, you can deduct 3 points and add 3 FROM EACH SEASON. You can have three goes in each round, but have to give the chance for another person to answer. PLEASE SAY WHAT YOU ADDED AND DEDUCTED ”

You can vote a maximum of three times, but you need to allow at least one other person to vote inbetween each of your goes. I think that means you can't just bung two votes together and add and subtract six from each season.

Hope that helps
garbage456
21-04-2007
OK then here goes re adjusted,

Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 7
The Empty Child 50 (+3)
The Doctor Dances 30
The Parting of the Ways 23


Season 2

School Reunion 20 (+3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 26 (-3)
The Impossible Planet 28
The Satan Pit 30
Army of Ghosts 2
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
david@payne01.f
21-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 9 (+2)
The Empty Child 51 (+1)
The Doctor Dances 30
The Parting of the Ways 23


Season 2

School Reunion 21 (+1)
The Girl in the Fireplace 23 (-3)
The Impossible Planet 29 (+1)
The Satan Pit 31 (+1)
Army of Ghosts 2
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
joscos
21-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 7 (-2)
The Empty Child 51
The Doctor Dances 28 (-1)
The Parting of the Ways 25 (+3)


Season 2

School Reunion 18 (-3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 23
The Impossible Planet 29
The Satan Pit 31
Army of Ghosts 5 (+3)
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
garbage456
22-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 10 (+3)
The Empty Child 51
The Doctor Dances 28
The Parting of the Ways 25


Season 2

School Reunion 21 (+3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 20 (-3)
The Impossible Planet 29
The Satan Pit 31
Army of Ghosts 5
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
tardis_princess
22-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 12 (+2)
The Empty Child 51(+3)
The Doctor Dances 28(+3)
The Parting of the Ways 25


Season 2

School Reunion 21
The Girl in the Fireplace 23 (+3)
The Impossible Planet 28(-1)
The Satan Pit 31
Army of Ghosts 7(+2)
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
garbage456 is online now Report Bad Post Reply With Quote
david@payne01.f
22-04-2007
Season 1

Dalek 19
Father's Day 15 (+3)
The Empty Child 51
The Doctor Dances 25(-3)
The Parting of the Ways 25


Season 2

School Reunion 24(+3)
The Girl in the Fireplace 20 (-3)
The Impossible Planet 28
The Satan Pit 31
Army of Ghosts 7
Doomsday 23

ELIMINATED:

World War Three (S1)
End of the World (S1)
Boom Town (S1)
New Earth (S2)
Love and Monsters (S2)
Fear Her (S2)
Aliens of London (S1)
The Long Game (S1)
The Idiot's Lantern (S2)
Age of Steel (S2)
Rose (S1)
Rise of the Cybermen (S2)
Bad Wolf (S1)
The Unquiet Dead (S1)
Tooth and Claw (S2)
Silent Timelord
22-04-2007
can we now say that we can only deduct points?
<<
<
3 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map