Antony Hansen
Ben Ellis
Chris Barton
Craig Chalmers
Daniel Boys
Johndeep More
Keith Jack
Lee Mead
Lewis Bradley
Rob McVeigh
Seamus Cullen

I'll request a poll
Last edited by kyri : 15-04-2007 at 00:04

Daniel for the voice. That could change over the weeks. I wonder if Chris B is as good a dancer as was stated by one of the panel tonight.

Who's yours?

pmsl



Lee for me so far.
Next Daniel
and Craig - something about him I like

Hmmm..toughy. I liked Keith,Johndeep, Ben and Lee. If i had to choose at the moment it would be Keith.

Btw MetalMonkey look at Seamus' name where you quoted me. That's the last time i copy from Wikipedia!

I just realised. I copied them in order from wikipedia Johndeep was also under Johnny Deep

i like lee and daniel!

I've just put on my glasses. How did that change, I don't remenber doing it. Must be a grelim in the system!!!! And I can't put in the LAUGHING smilie for some reason!
Last edited by MetalMonkey : 15-04-2007 at 01:02

*chuckles* , unfortunately for Johndeep, every time he comes on screen my kids yell "Mr Bean!!"

I got goosebumps when Daniel sang tonight and its probably a good job i cant vote (damn work!!!), cos i'd have spent a few pence chucking him some votes

Lee is my favourite, although i also like Daniel, Keith and Johndeep.

Daniel is fave in our house by far, followed by Lewis.

Seamus

Lewis!

I can't seem to decide at all at the moment, as there are several I really like. It's definitely between Rob, Seamus, Daniel and Keith though.

Daniel - by a mile for his voice and that glint that the others lack.


Followed by:

Johndeep - my second favourite vocally
Seamus - my second favourite visually

Lee - good but a bit "nothing" - you can almost see and hear why he has been and still is just an understudy

Rob - did very well last night considering he was the least experienced and first one on

Craig - there's something about him I like though I don' think he's been anywhere near as good on this so far as he was on PI.


Miles behind:

Lewis - the looks and life of a shop window dummy
Chris B - ditto
Antony - nowhere near as good as he thinks he is
Ben - did very well in the sing-off though
Keith - good voice but so did some others who weren't put through because they were "not right for the part"

Daniel - Great voice, and seems very likeable personality wise.

Chris B - Very good, but could easily begin to annoy me over coming weeks.
Lewis - For the tan and the hair: so cheesy, so boyband. It can only make me love him.

Between Daniel, Lee and Chris B.

I agree with the post above that i'm not sure if Lee has that extra 'something' but out of anyone he has the full package at the moment.

He's kinda like the Connie of this year, in that he is the safe option but doesn't have the spark and star quality of some of the others (I prefer Lee to Connie though).

Front runners:

Daniel
Johndeep (but I am concerned about the acting side - I wait and hope)
Lee (Actually my front runner but I can see Daniel stepping up to the line quickly)
Seamus
Rob

Outsider : Ben.

I don't rate the rest for various reasons. Voices that, while undoubtedly good, don't stand out. The 'plastic' demeanours. The Donovan lookalikes. The unreal teeth - so big and white they look like those sweetie gums you used to buy.
Last edited by Kez100 : 15-04-2007 at 13:05

I think Daniel's voice is fantastic but I am not sure he looks like my Joseph should look. I hope he gets something out of this programme as he is very talented.

Seamus has my look but can't stand the guy, he comes across as arrogant altho maybe that is maturity- NO it isn't he is arrogant!
I think Keith is fantastic but perhaps too young for Joseph but surely there will be work for him somewhere in west end. Same for Ben (isn't he the spit of Matt Willis? )

BoB the builder and John Deep don't do it for me either - oh and can I comment if his family are so deep into their culture how come his sister was dressed very westernised?

Craig and Lewis are too cheesey for me so guess that leaves my favourite as Lee but it could change

And why did Chris leave his amazing perfomance until his throwing out song. That was a amzing and if he had sung like that earlier he wouldn't have deserved to go out

Daniel Boys is my favourite, although i also like Ben Ellis, Seamen Cullen and Lewis Bradley.

Just going on last night's show, Daniel was the 'wow' performance for me. He wasn't one I remembered from the earlier shows but I thought he was fantastic. Incredibly high standard, though. Much better than most of these programmes. I think it's impossible to tell yet.

Out of interest, do you think any could have been Danny in Grease?

Daniel
Lee
Rob

I think this needs a whole other thread and with the more threads we have maybe we will get our own subform. Will you start it or will I?

Keith, Daniel and Lee are my top three - though I have a slight soft spot for Rob (but enough of the "builder" mentions, please!) and Antony (who, I think, COULD be great).

Lee, Antony and Rob!

I like Lewis, Lee, Johndeep and Seamus