I think it should be Craig as was surprised he wasn't in the bottom 2 on the first show.

Agree with you unless he improves this week.

I didn't enjoy Antonys performance. It was the worst one for me, but I guess the shots of his girlfriend weeping had the desired effect on the gbp.

Sad to say Craig was weak in the vocal department so I really hope he gets over the nerves this week.

Lewis to go for me.

Craig and Chris B get my vote to go. Wasn't overly impresed by Ben, either.

Craig, Anthony or Ben.

The young boy with the dark hair (the youngest contestant?), going by his performance on last week's show.

That's Anthony... the one that sang Aerosmith's "I don't want to miss a thing"

Think Anthony should go and get on with his A Levels.

Plus the realisation that he's not as good as he thinks he is might help him learn some humility.

Haha! I think Anthony should go as well... but if you watching in the two group performances, he's really striking and does stand out and act well!! Oh dear!

I agree with most people on here.....(based on his performance last week) Anthony to go.....

anthony i thought he was the worst on saturday by quite a bit

I hope Craigs the next one to go, i just can't warm to him at all. Failing that i'd be quite happy to wave goodbye to Anthony too - i was surprised that he gained such good comments for a rather patchy performance.

Based on last week's performances, definitely Anthony or Ben - both were really struggling to stay in tune.

I think Keith should go next. I really don't get why he appeals to so many people (most of which are my friends ).

However, I think either Anthony, Craig or possibly Ben will go next, judging by the comments on here.

I will be surprised if Ben is in the bottom 2 next week. The GBP always vote for the underdog so I reckon that will save him next week

Craig to go next week.

At least he got further in this than he did in Pop Idol 2

Re: Post #3 - I think Antony should go actually, not Lewis (he can go the week after ) as Antony was dismal. Karaoke even. But, he is a favourite with Denise "I love him" and Zoe "I like Antony too" Shame they can't stick to the script and give proper critiques without the personality likes and dislikes. It's Joseph we are looking for and the person most equipped for the job, not the cutest bum or twinkliest grin. (Although cute bums are welcome lol) John B had words with Seamus for being over-controlling and the one who was saying he was too controlling was.......Antony. Hmmm. We might be lumped with him for a while.

I went to school with Chris's brother Nick B.

My head says Craig, Ben or Johndeep to go this week, depending on performances. They're the weakest at the minute. But I'd like to get rid of Keith or one of the pretty-boy-blond-Josephs (Chris or Lewis).

I think the 'Luck Be A Lady' performance was very interesting last week. Rob and Antony did much better than of the others (including the clear favourites Lee and Daniel). They had pretty tough songs with not very smooth melodies last week; I suspect these two will do better than people think over the coming weeks.

My friend knows Craig and he can do better so not Craig... I honestly feel Ben...

Anthony or Craig. Anthony is just appalling and Craig is dull.

I'm sorry, I haven't got the names yet, but I really don't like the guy with the plastic hair and teeth. I can't even remember what he sang.

He looks (to me) like the Australian comedian Bob Downe - but as most people probably don't remember him, that probably won't help anyone to know which Joseph I mean

Edit: Just had a look on the website, and I mean Craig
Last edited by looby383x : 20-04-2007 at 11:37

Hmm.......why all the fuss...the result is already pre determined as it was with Maria.

Last night they used the typical "shock result" tactic to keep interest running high.....and they'll use it again.Also watch out for the "public apathy" result.....that stirs things up too.

Until these shows are subject to full independent vote scrutiny , the public will get ripped off. The fact that some of the money from the voting goes to charitie(s) doesn't excuse the tactics they use.
In a situation like this , when viewers are paying to vote , each nights voting figures should be made available having been checked and verified.

Watch out also for..............."Keep those votes coming in , it's so close".....thats short hand for a low poll

Call me cynical ............. but nothing in TV is left to chance.

Craig or Ben to go out next for me

Can you prove that statement? What you've said is downright libellous...

The truth is they don't need to 'fix it' because that's why they have the backup plan of ALW choosing who goes home each week. That's ensuring that the ones he wants stay in.

Don't you think if these shows were fixed it would have been all over the tabloids by now?


Yes because during the show they are going to ruin the unknown of the voting public's opinion by posting the voting figures. That will really help their viewing figures...

Of course even if they didn't release the voting figures you'd still have people saying they were made up so they can't exactly win.