It was gonna go one way or the other for her. She is very 'Marmite'.

Alas! Too late to save Rose, or even Donna! Although I'm broadly neutral about Grace. But some astonishing results so far which speak of unreasonably retro tastes. Shame on you all.

It's +2 for Peri, +1 for Martha, and -3 from Captain Jack from me. I *really* would have knocked some off from the squealy Jo Grant and the bleepy K9, but 24 is just ridiculous for the smarmy wonder, so everything comes off the Captain (ooh, matron).

Susan Foreman 7
Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 20
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 15
Turlough 11
Peri Brown 10
Ace 11
Captain Jack Harkness 21
Martha Jones 15

Eliminated:

Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Susan Foreman 4 (-3)
Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 20
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 16 (+2)
Turlough 11
Peri Brown 10
Ace 11
Captain Jack Harkness 21
Martha Jones 16 (+1)

Eliminated:

Adric (He was first eliminated, but no one remembers lol)
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway
Last edited by joscos : 18-04-2007 at 17:13

Susan Foreman 4
Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 20
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 11
Peri Brown 7 (- 3)
Ace 11
Captain Jack Harkness 24 (+3)
Martha Jones 16

Eliminated:

Adric
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Susan Foreman 4
Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 22(+2)
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10(-1)
Peri Brown 6(-1)
Ace 10(-1)
Captain Jack Harkness 25(+1)
Martha Jones 16

Eliminated:

Adric
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Susan Foreman 1 - 3
Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 23 +1
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 11 +1
Peri Brown 6
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 26 +1
Martha Jones 16

Susan Foreman 1
Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 23
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 11
Peri Brown 3 (-3)
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 29 (+3)
Martha Jones 16

No Nyssa, Brigadier, Zoe or Steven?

Susan Foreman 0 *Eliminated -1
Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 24 +1
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 12 +1
Peri Brown 1 - 2
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 30 +1
Martha Jones 16

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 26(+2)
Romana 10
K-9 16
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10(-2)
Peri Brown 0(-1) eliminated
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 31(+1)
Martha Jones 16

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 14
Sarah Jane Smith 27 (+1)
Romana 10
K-9 17 (+1)
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10
Ace 11 (+1 purely for the baseball bat and homemade explosives)
Captain Jack Harkness 28 (-3)
Martha Jones 16

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

PS - Romana I or Romana II?

both of them, i just counted her as one character.

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 11 (-3)
Sarah Jane Smith 27
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10
Ace 11
Captain Jack Harkness 28
Martha Jones 19 (+3)

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 8 - 3
Sarah Jane Smith 27
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10
Ace 11
Captain Jack Harkness 31 +3
Martha Jones 19

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

It all depends how you define "companion" in this case. If you count people who have travelled in the Tardis then surely Capt Jack should count as shoulw Mickey and the ex-Corrie actor from the first Dalek story

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 8
Sarah Jane Smith 27
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10
Ace 14 +3
Captain Jack Harkness 28 -3
Martha Jones 19

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 11 +3
Sarah Jane Smith 27
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10
Ace 11 - 3
Captain Jack Harkness 28
Martha Jones 19

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

I'm surprised that Capt Jack has so many votes and Ace so few

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 11
Sarah Jane Smith 29(+2)
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 8(-2)
Ace 10(-1)
Captain Jack Harkness 29(+1)
Martha Jones 19

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

What happened to poor old Adiric. He went and no one noticed. A bit like in the series.
Sorry forgot to read page 2 before I posted.
Last edited by Greenwood : 19-04-2007 at 14:13

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 8 (-3)
Sarah Jane Smith 29
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 8
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 29
Martha Jones 22 (+3)

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 8
Sarah Jane Smith 29
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 8
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 26(-3)
Martha Jones 25 (+3)

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 8
Sarah Jane Smith 32 (+3)
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 8
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 23(-3)
Martha Jones 25

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 5 (-3)
Sarah Jane Smith 32
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 8
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 26(+3)
Martha Jones 25

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway

Jamie McCrimmon 10
Jo Grant 2 -3
Sarah Jane Smith 32
Romana 10
K-9 17
Tegan Jovanka 16
Turlough 10 + 2
Ace 10
Captain Jack Harkness 27 +1
Martha Jones 25

Eliminated:
Adric
Peri Brown
Rose Tyler
Donna Noble
Dr Grace Holloway