Last night was Disco themed with guest judge Verdine White from Earth, Wind, and Fire. Wow, that guy is scary!

There really isn’t much to say about the show. Nobody was spectacular, IMO. I think Carmen had her best performance so far. But the pants she wore were hideous! Clay sort of let me down. I felt like he was dragging out the notes too much. He also just stood there doing nothing. Move your body, boy! I actually laughed all the way through Josh’s performance of “Celebrate.”

My predictions for bottom three: Rickey, Kim Caldwell, Josh

I do have to mention that I have my very own Simon in my life. I realized yesterday that my Organic Chemistry professor is Simon’s twin! My professor:

-wears his pants too high
-wears tight short sleeve shirts that are black or white
-has man breasts
-is British

Sorry but I forgot to put a spoiler warning on that last post.

*SPOILER*



Whew! That was a close one. I was soooo wrong about the bottom three. Kim Locke, TRENYCE ( ), and Carmen. They let Kim go first. Then they had Trenyce and Carmen perform. Turns out NOBODY is going home this week. I was so afraid we were about to see another Tamyra Gray incident. The votes will carry over to next week so I will be sure to cast MANY votes for Trenyce.

Simon said one of the guys was lucky and deserved to get the boot. Personally, I think that comment was directed towards Josh. Okay, that's all for now!

~Jessica

Aww not Carmen

That puts her at a disadvantage then coz she had the lowest votes this week I assume... but everyone can be voted out next week can't they?

Yeah, anyone can be voted out next week. Maybe I'll put in a few Carmen votes for you, Ben.

could you put in a few more votes for Carmen for me please!!!.
there all so great i don't want anyone to go.
the top 10 is so strong but Rickey to go!!!!

Can't believe that Trenyce was bottom 2, I thought she was great

But keep the lovely Carmen in, I like her

I have to agree with Simon. One of them is in the right job at the right time.

i think up to now josh has been great,this wasnt his best performance but hey not everyone can be great every week,,call me synical but i think trenyce was in the bottom 3 because of her theft charge i think it was,with people saying if corey can get voted off why not her,,, my only complaint was kimberly locke didnt deserve to be in the bottom 3 ,the other kimberly did though

Hmm!

I agree with Simon, the right people were not chosen tonight.

Carmen is cute, and sang well tonight. Actually I agree with Simon that she is the most commercially viable of the girls(and outside the US certainly, of any of them with the right song and marketing).

She hasn't the best voice . That would be Reuben, but trust me this sort of thing will not sell outside the US, ditto Trenyce. Clay Josh , Ricky and Kim Locke

As the singles market is pretty irrelevant in the US, or so I'm told, how did last years crop go?

I've seen massive Avril worldwide sales, but not Kelly Clarkson.How did she go in the Us and the others?

So how will these people sell in the Us? No idea! But I'd doubt they'd be challenging Eminem, Avril and Nelly for the biggest album next year! Good voices, but it's all been done better before.

Actually, although not the technically best competitors the two cds I would like on a desert island , as the question went tonight, would be Carmen and Kim Caldwell

thank god noone left last night were people who voted watching the same show as me

trenyce and kim locke were two of the best the two who were a long way behind the others were josh nodding head and rickey who sounded higher than a drug addict on helium

i also like kim c but think clay or reuben will probably win

Throw in a few votes to Carmen from me as well. She had the guts to sing a very difficult song and even gave it a bit of something different. How many words in one sentance?

Go Carmen (and Trenyce).