Who do you think he would cast as Joseph?
If it was down to Andrew...
I think that Lee would be an obvious choice for him, or Daniel. Lewis is also an obvious one, but ALW will be watching him very carefully to see how he copes during the contest, since he is so young.
I think its very difficult to tell specifically out of the finalists which he would chose. I think he will change his mind as the performances progress. Its much more of a mixed back this time, more difficult to chose. But I would say for certain that he would have Lewis if his vocal and other qualities matched up to his looks. He looks like this pop star type role he requested.
It depends what he's actually really looking for.
Lookswise, he would probably go for someone like Lewis. God knows why but there seem to be some people of an opinion that he's something to write home about.
Vocally, probably someone like Daniel, Lee, Seamus, Rob or even Keith, though I think the world's greatest make-up artist would struggle to get Keith to look the part.
If he is after someone who can be depended upon to do the role justice, it has to be Daniel, Lee or Seamus. However, if he isn't willing to contemplate somebody else's opinions and input, it has to be Lee out of those three.
Lookswise, he would probably go for someone like Lewis. God knows why but there seem to be some people of an opinion that he's something to write home about.
Vocally, probably someone like Daniel, Lee, Seamus, Rob or even Keith, though I think the world's greatest make-up artist would struggle to get Keith to look the part.
If he is after someone who can be depended upon to do the role justice, it has to be Daniel, Lee or Seamus. However, if he isn't willing to contemplate somebody else's opinions and input, it has to be Lee out of those three.
Originally Posted by sHAYneWARD:
“It depends what he's actually really looking for.
Lookswise, he would probably go for someone like Lewis. God knows why but there seem to be some people of an opinion that he's something to write home about.
Vocally, probably someone like Daniel, Lee, Seamus, Rob or even Keith, though I think the world's greatest make-up artist would struggle to get Keith to look the part.
If he is after someone who can be depended upon to do the role justice, it has to be Daniel, Lee or Seamus. However, if he isn't willing to contemplate somebody else's opinions and input, it has to be Lee out of those three.”
“It depends what he's actually really looking for.
Lookswise, he would probably go for someone like Lewis. God knows why but there seem to be some people of an opinion that he's something to write home about.
Vocally, probably someone like Daniel, Lee, Seamus, Rob or even Keith, though I think the world's greatest make-up artist would struggle to get Keith to look the part.
If he is after someone who can be depended upon to do the role justice, it has to be Daniel, Lee or Seamus. However, if he isn't willing to contemplate somebody else's opinions and input, it has to be Lee out of those three.”
Couldn't agree more.
Quote:
“If he is after someone who can be depended upon to do the role justice, it has to be Daniel, Lee or Seamus. However, if he isn't willing to contemplate somebody else's opinions and input, it has to be Lee out of those three.”
“If he is after someone who can be depended upon to do the role justice, it has to be Daniel, Lee or Seamus. However, if he isn't willing to contemplate somebody else's opinions and input, it has to be Lee out of those three.”
Seconded.
Stop right there people!! 
Daniel is by far the more talented, it is so obvious that i shouldn't even have to be saying it.
Daniel is by far the more talented, it is so obvious that i shouldn't even have to be saying it.
As much as i like Daniel im not sure if he's one of Andrews favourites. He seemed quite critical of him in week one (saying that he didn't connect with the song etc) and again last week he wasn't exactly overly praising him.
I think ALW seems to be looking for a young "pin-up" Joseph, hence sending the guys to perform with McFly and all this talk of a Justin Timberlake inspired choice unfortunately for him the younger lads such as Anthony and Ben really dont deliver so i'd guess Lewis would be high on his list of candidates.
Personally he does nothing for me (give me Lee anyday!
) but then again i never really rated Jason Donovan much as Joseph.
I think ALW seems to be looking for a young "pin-up" Joseph, hence sending the guys to perform with McFly and all this talk of a Justin Timberlake inspired choice unfortunately for him the younger lads such as Anthony and Ben really dont deliver so i'd guess Lewis would be high on his list of candidates.
Personally he does nothing for me (give me Lee anyday!
) but then again i never really rated Jason Donovan much as Joseph.
Originally Posted by haggy-me:
“As much as i like Daniel im not sure if he's one of Andrews favourites. He seemed quite critical of him in week one (saying that he didn't connect with the song etc) and again last week he wasn't exactly overly praising him.
I think ALW seems to be looking for a young "pin-up" Joseph, hence sending the guys to perform with McFly and all this talk of a Justin Timberlake inspired choice unfortunately for him the younger lads such as Anthony and Ben really dont deliver so i'd guess Lewis would be high on his list of candidates.
Personally he does nothing for me (give me Lee anyday! ) but then again i never really rated Jason Donovan much as Joseph.”
“As much as i like Daniel im not sure if he's one of Andrews favourites. He seemed quite critical of him in week one (saying that he didn't connect with the song etc) and again last week he wasn't exactly overly praising him.
I think ALW seems to be looking for a young "pin-up" Joseph, hence sending the guys to perform with McFly and all this talk of a Justin Timberlake inspired choice unfortunately for him the younger lads such as Anthony and Ben really dont deliver so i'd guess Lewis would be high on his list of candidates.
Personally he does nothing for me (give me Lee anyday!
) but then again i never really rated Jason Donovan much as Joseph.”
I have to agree with you, i get the feeling ALW is looking for someone young and good looking rather than talented.
I have seen Daniel on stage and he is amazing, all the others could probably be Joseph, but how well do you want the job done?
The poor guys not that old yet! I think you mean Reuben. he has a solo so that would give him his moment.
