and the right one won!

I liked them both but all my favourites come in third (Darius)

I will be happy if this Joseph is a repeat and Ben comes in third

Will Young and Gareth Gates is a good example, all the spouting of how much better Gareth was than Will, who has released more successful albums, sold out more tour dates, appeared in a film done a three month theatre run in Manchester and what did a certain so called Judge say?

At the end of the day it will be the Great British Public who will decide and not just fanatics on forums who support one or the other!

May the best one be JOSEPH and hopefully we will all accept that.

I agree (as long as it's Lee )

Those were good times. I remember all the conspiracy theories that people had, with Gareth fans claiming they could not get phone calls through on the final night. And then the book came up saying that Will had won 6 out of the 9 live shows. Aw I miss the Pop Idol rivalry