Lee still my favourite but I do think Ben has stepped up a gear on last night's show, and he did well in the Les Mis mission.
Keith and Daniel will make up the final four.
Keith and Daniel will make up the final four.
Results:Week 5 - Any Dream Will Do: Favourite Joseph
Ben Ellis
15 (6.30%)
Craig Chalmers
7 (2.94%)
Daniel Boys
61 (25.63%)
Keith Jack
50 (21.01%)
Lee Mead
90 (37.82%)
Lewis Bradley
8 (3.36%)
Rob McVeigh
7 (2.94%)
Voters: 238. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Week 5 - Any Dream Will Do: Favourite Joseph
2 of 4
1) Lee
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.
Still making noise for Daniel Boys - even though he wasn't too sharp this week!
(Keith is catching him up though; he was excellent last night)
(Keith is catching him up though; he was excellent last night)
Originally Posted by Mr Bickle:
“1) Lee
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.”
“1) Lee
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.”
I would agree with that.
Still Lee for me
The only other possibility IMO is Daniel.
Keith i just don't see it at all. Yes he has a good voice but as for Saturday night - any of the boys could have sang that song as well if not better.
Its easy to give the best performance when you are given the best and easiest song to sing.
The only other possibility IMO is Daniel.
Keith i just don't see it at all. Yes he has a good voice but as for Saturday night - any of the boys could have sang that song as well if not better.
Its easy to give the best performance when you are given the best and easiest song to sing.
Has to be Lee - he wasn't on form on Saturday vocally but I thought his actual performance was ace!
I think he has masses of Charisma and a wonderful stage presence. More than any of the others.
Keith was vocally amazing - still have to be convinced of his star quality. But what a voice!
I think he has masses of Charisma and a wonderful stage presence. More than any of the others.
Keith was vocally amazing - still have to be convinced of his star quality. But what a voice!
Originally Posted by lilhunni_Jo:
“Keith all the way!”
“Keith all the way!”
I do respect other peoples opinions, but how can you think that anyone who cries in a loin cloth in front of his mum can possibly perform in front of huge audiences in the west end???? You surely don't just need to be a good singer, you also need to be mature with a strong personality, and a lot of self-confidence.
It's not his fault, it's just his age!
Originally Posted by Mr Bickle:
“1) Lee
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.”
“1) Lee
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.”
Totally agree with that!
Originally Posted by Mr Bickle:
“1) Lee
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.”
“1) Lee
2) Daniel
3) Keith
They are the only three in it for me. Lee and Daniel are the most accomplished and are the only two who actually "sell" the performance.
Keith has the best voice but, sadly, just doesn't look the part. He has a great future, though.”
They would be my top three too, perhaps with Keith interchangeable with Lewis or Rob as a "whole package".
I can't agree in a million years with Keith having the best voice. It's not a patch on Lee's, or even Lewis' (or the sadly gone too soon Seamus and Johndeep) and millions of leagues from Daniel's.
Sure, Keith can hit the right notes nicely (as long as they're within his rather limited register) but nicely is all and nicely is not enough.
He doesn't have the ability to convey the emotion of a song with his voice (therefore, he would not make a good recording artist), and is unable to convey the emotion of a song by acting which, paired with his less than good looks, would make him unsuitable as a stage performer.
Unfortunate for him but such is life.
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“Keith for me... followed by Ben”
“Keith for me... followed by Ben”
If we could have Ben's looks and acting ability and Keith's voice then I think we have found our perfect Joseph
Originally Posted by STS:
“Still Lee for me.
He didn't make any excuses - the panel were the ones who talked about him being ill and John Barrowman even stated that Lee didn't moan and just got on with it. Not his best week, but it showed he's a pro. He sold a rubbish song IMHO.”
“Still Lee for me.
He didn't make any excuses - the panel were the ones who talked about him being ill and John Barrowman even stated that Lee didn't moan and just got on with it. Not his best week, but it showed he's a pro. He sold a rubbish song IMHO.”
He didn't make any excuses in front of the camera. He left his hissy fit for behind the scenes. Very clever, Queenie.
Alrgiht Now is a great song. Far too big for Lee. His huge limitations, and the reasons why despite all his training (and despite trying full-time since his teens) he hasn't been able to make it in his chosen profession until now, were highlighted like a neon sign for each and every viewer to see this week.
It was a shame because I have always thought and still think that he is among the best three in this show.
Originally Posted by Forever Awkward:
“He didn't make any excuses in front of the camera. He left his hissy fit for behind the scenes. Very clever, Queenie.
Alrgiht Now is a great song. Far too big for Lee. His huge limitations, and the reasons why despite all his training (and despite trying full-time since his teens) he hasn't been able to make it in his chosen profession until now, were highlighted like a neon sign for each and every viewer to see this week.”
“He didn't make any excuses in front of the camera. He left his hissy fit for behind the scenes. Very clever, Queenie.
Alrgiht Now is a great song. Far too big for Lee. His huge limitations, and the reasons why despite all his training (and despite trying full-time since his teens) he hasn't been able to make it in his chosen profession until now, were highlighted like a neon sign for each and every viewer to see this week.”
So how was the show? Did you enjoy it?
Originally Posted by twingle:
“If we could have Ben's looks and acting ability and Keith's voice then I think we have found our perfect Joseph”
“If we could have Ben's looks and acting ability and Keith's voice then I think we have found our perfect Joseph”
If we could have Ben's acting ability and Keith's voice, I think we would be somewhere near finding an also-ran.
Originally Posted by STS:
“So how was the show? Did you enjoy it?”
“So how was the show? Did you enjoy it?”
Generally, yes, thanks for asking
2 of 4
