Craig for me

Craig or Rob. I would say Ben, but he has presence and the looks.

If I have to pick one I would say Craig.

Don't like Craig or Lewis at all.

I like Ben and think he has a future but he isn't vocally good enough at this point same with, similarly with Rob.

Least favourite Joseph is a tie between Rob and Lewis for me. Daniel also has given me doubts now.

Rob - has shown last night that he doesn't do the 'soft' approach well. Talented he is, my Joseph he ain't.

Lewis - I find his dancing awkward, and dare I say, almost comical. He hasn't impressed me with his vocals.

Daniel - sorry, but it's his expression. Perma-smile. I'm sure that's why I see a bit of Steve Martin about him. He has a face that smiles through the eyes which is wonderful, but not all the time. He's still holder of my second favourite performance with "You Give Me" which is perfect Daniel stuff. I'm not sure about him being Joseph though.

lewis

hes gettin worse

Out of those left, it has to be:

Ben for his comparative lack of vocal talent
Keith for his wrong look
Lee for his lack of personality

Ben. Then Craig. Then Keith.

I think it has been said before that if you give people half-witted "smiley" songs you are going to get a"smiley" expression!

Really?!

Vocally: Ben

In terms of acting talent, overall suitability, general look, inability to convey any emotion whatsoever and general stamina necessary for the part: Keith

Spot on! How else are you supposed to perform songs like "You Give Me Something", "The Lady is a Tramp" and particularly "It's All About You". I didn't see a lot of smiling throughout "Since You've Been Gone", except for at the very beginning and very appropriately for the line "We started out friends", despite the fact that ALW seemed to pick up the point that Daniel had chosen to express joy

When it comes to the group songs, Daniel is one of the few who has conveyed the song they have been performing and, particularly in the case of rockier numbers, one of the few who has looked and sounded appropriate for the song.

Rob, for being furthest from my idea of Joseph.


True. This week I started wondering if ALW is doing that intentionally because Daniel wouldn't take his advice and went for smiley with 'Since You've Been Gone'...

Daniel's had smiley ever since and I'm assuming ALW has a large part in choosing the songs.

Ben for me

Lewis

Lewis

Lewis

Rob closely followed by Craig and Lewis.

I actually find it hard to choose after Saturday night. I think all of them (apart from Keith ) were given terrible songs to sing.

Ben and Rob were probably the worst out of a bad bunch.

So although Rob looks less like Joseph, i'm going to go for Ben this week, as he is definitely the weaker of the two vocally.

Hmmm...
Least favourite: Craig, just because I remember him from when he was in Pop Idol second series and as soon as I saw him he annoyed me. Also don't think he's giving his all, in fact, he often looks bored.
Out of their depth: Lewis and Ben.
Has talent but doesn't look right: Rob. Bless him, good voice, seems like a nice bloke, but not a Joseph.
Leaving Daniel, Keith and Lee.
On the subject of Daniel, I still don't know why he went with the smileyness with Since you've been gone... he smiled more than once and that just didn't work! The song's about being hurt and used and finally breaking free... I suppose it could be interpreted as joyful, but not quite smiley-joyful. All the songs he's been given could have been played different from smiley... good point from John Barrowman on Saturday that you just have to work with the songs you're given.
Most of the songs were awful on Saturday. Who chose Lionel Ritchie?! Who?! Feel ashamed!!! What are we going to get next week, "Hello"?!
Lol just realised the lyrics in that: "Hello... is it me you're looking for?"... smacks rather of desperation in the context of this competition!

Rob is my least favourite. Just don't see him as being suitable - sorry.