simon
tre
katie
kristina
ghazal
lohit
jadine
naomi
tre
katie
kristina
ghazal
lohit
jadine
naomi
Rank the Candidates - Post Adam firing
2 of 3
lohit
kristina
naomi
jadine
tre
simon
katie
ghazal
Although that said naomi and jadine have taken a back seat in the program in the past couple of weeks, although i think naomi could potentially go quite far unless she really cocks up. I think lohit is the dark horse though, he's been good every time we've seen him and at the same time kept his head down and not gotten involved in the politics and seems to work well with even the most difficult of the contenders which IMO is the most important skill to have and is what Sirallan wants.
kristina
naomi
jadine
tre
simon
katie
ghazal
Although that said naomi and jadine have taken a back seat in the program in the past couple of weeks, although i think naomi could potentially go quite far unless she really cocks up. I think lohit is the dark horse though, he's been good every time we've seen him and at the same time kept his head down and not gotten involved in the politics and seems to work well with even the most difficult of the contenders which IMO is the most important skill to have and is what Sirallan wants.
1. Kristina - It just has to be Kristina to win. She's smart and does well in every task. She went and got dopey Paul's sausages cooked for him and she won by a mile when she was team leader. Gotta love her forcing the parents to pay for the lolly too at the zoo!
9.5/10
2. Jadine - Been quiet these last few weeka but i really do think shes got what it takes. She seems to have taken notice of Sugar's warning about being disruptive but by keeping her head down she has not drawn attention to herself and shes been on the winning team for 3 or 4 weeks now. She won her task as team leader and shes tough and speaks her mind. 9
3. Tre - Not sure if he has what it takes to win but the guy is smart and funny and speaks his mind - and he makes me laugh every week. Won his task as team leader. 8.5
4. Lohit - I think there's more to him than we are seeing atm. 7.5
5. Naomi - Same as Lohit. We haven't seen the best of this one. She was poor as team leader but it would be interesting to see how she'd perform doing it a second time. 7
6. Simon - Don't care much for him to be honest but i have to put him ahead of Ghazel and Katie. The guy is a total waste of space though in my opinion. 5.5
7. Katie - The womans not stupid and shes smarter than Simon by a mile. But shes simply a nasty piece of work and i find her very patronising too. Wouldn't trust her as far as i could throw her. 5
8. Ghazal - Well what can you say really? I did think that much like Lohit and Naomi there was a bit more to this one than we were seeing. I was wrong. The womans a waste of space. 4.5
I'd like to see Katie go next [mostly cos i'm sick of her solo chats to the camera all the time] after that Ghazal and simon i don't care in what order - but maybe together in a double firing would be cool. After that i'd like to see Lohit and Noami proving themselves like i feel they can. The other 3 are serious contenders and if they aren't in the last 4 i'll be surprised.
9.5/102. Jadine - Been quiet these last few weeka but i really do think shes got what it takes. She seems to have taken notice of Sugar's warning about being disruptive but by keeping her head down she has not drawn attention to herself and shes been on the winning team for 3 or 4 weeks now. She won her task as team leader and shes tough and speaks her mind. 9
3. Tre - Not sure if he has what it takes to win but the guy is smart and funny and speaks his mind - and he makes me laugh every week. Won his task as team leader. 8.5
4. Lohit - I think there's more to him than we are seeing atm. 7.5
5. Naomi - Same as Lohit. We haven't seen the best of this one. She was poor as team leader but it would be interesting to see how she'd perform doing it a second time. 7
6. Simon - Don't care much for him to be honest but i have to put him ahead of Ghazel and Katie. The guy is a total waste of space though in my opinion. 5.5
7. Katie - The womans not stupid and shes smarter than Simon by a mile. But shes simply a nasty piece of work and i find her very patronising too. Wouldn't trust her as far as i could throw her. 5
8. Ghazal - Well what can you say really? I did think that much like Lohit and Naomi there was a bit more to this one than we were seeing. I was wrong. The womans a waste of space. 4.5
I'd like to see Katie go next [mostly cos i'm sick of her solo chats to the camera all the time] after that Ghazal and simon i don't care in what order - but maybe together in a double firing would be cool. After that i'd like to see Lohit and Noami proving themselves like i feel they can. The other 3 are serious contenders and if they aren't in the last 4 i'll be surprised.
1. Kristina
2. Tre
3. Naomi
4. Jadine
5. Lohit
6. Simon
7. Ghazel
8. Katie
Thats the order I'd most like them to win. However I wouldn't be sad to lose Naomi, Lohit or Ghazel because I don't think they add anything to the programme. I want Katie to last until the episodes before the final. In fact, if we say there are going to be four in the final, this is the order I'd like the others to be eliminated:
1. Ghazel (out next week)
2. Lohit
3. Simon
4. Katie
And the other four to make the final (if that makes sense?)
2. Tre
3. Naomi
4. Jadine
5. Lohit
6. Simon
7. Ghazel
8. Katie
Thats the order I'd most like them to win. However I wouldn't be sad to lose Naomi, Lohit or Ghazel because I don't think they add anything to the programme. I want Katie to last until the episodes before the final. In fact, if we say there are going to be four in the final, this is the order I'd like the others to be eliminated:
1. Ghazel (out next week)
2. Lohit
3. Simon
4. Katie
And the other four to make the final (if that makes sense?)
Running Total:
(Up to post 33)
Points based on placing:
1st place = 8 points
2nd place = 7 points
3rd place = 6 points
4th place = 5 points
5th place = 4 points
6th place = 3 points
7th place = 2 points
8th place = 1 point
By the way, if anybody updates the running total then bear in mind that in the opening post I didn't actually post my own ranking choices, I was just naming the names of the 8 left who we have to choose from. So don't count them in your calculations.
Hopefully people can actually type the number of the place next to the respective names. It makes things a whole lot more easier when tallying up the scores.
(Up to post 33)
Points based on placing:
1st place = 8 points
2nd place = 7 points
3rd place = 6 points
4th place = 5 points
5th place = 4 points
6th place = 3 points
7th place = 2 points
8th place = 1 point
Code:
1. Kristina 220 (19.71%) 2. Lohit 185 (16.58%) 3. Tre 183 (16.40%) 4. Simon 136 (12.19%) 5. Naomi 134 (12.01%) 6. Jadine 127 (11.38%) 7. Katie 68 (6.09%) 8. Ghazal 63 (5.65%) Voters: 31
Hopefully people can actually type the number of the place next to the respective names. It makes things a whole lot more easier when tallying up the scores.
This is so difficult because I really don't rate or like any of them! I found an old video the other night which still had an episode of the first series on it. Without a shadow of a doubt I believe Saira, Miriam, James and Paul would have wiped the floor with any of this lot.
1. Lohit - As others have said he has kept his head down, done what has been asked of him and doesn't seem to be involved in any of the back-biting. Very Tim like.
2. Tre - A controversial choice but, I do think he could learn from SAS, and unlike many of the others what you see is what you get.
3. Jadine - I'm hoping her disappearance from our screens is because she's taken on board what SAS sand and not the result of clever editing.
4. Naomi - Hard to tell, but I'm guessing that despite her poor performance as PM, we're not seeing much of her because she's just getting on with it.
5. Simon - Didn't impress me as a PM and if the other team had put aside their personal differences with Adam, Simon would have been in the BR this week.
6. Kristina - I honestly don't believe she's a team player. I didn't rate Paul but, I do believe there was more than an element of truth in his statement regarding her criticising for the sake of it.
7. Katie - What can you say?
I'd only keep her in for the ratings. Love her or hate her she's bloody good TV.
8. Ghazal - I think she's way out of her depth. Like Simon she was very lucky to win her task, and out of those left she is by far the weakest contestant.
Last edited by *Laura* : 11-05-2007 at 15:02
1. Lohit - As others have said he has kept his head down, done what has been asked of him and doesn't seem to be involved in any of the back-biting. Very Tim like.
2. Tre - A controversial choice but, I do think he could learn from SAS, and unlike many of the others what you see is what you get.
3. Jadine - I'm hoping her disappearance from our screens is because she's taken on board what SAS sand and not the result of clever editing.
4. Naomi - Hard to tell, but I'm guessing that despite her poor performance as PM, we're not seeing much of her because she's just getting on with it.
5. Simon - Didn't impress me as a PM and if the other team had put aside their personal differences with Adam, Simon would have been in the BR this week.
6. Kristina - I honestly don't believe she's a team player. I didn't rate Paul but, I do believe there was more than an element of truth in his statement regarding her criticising for the sake of it.
7. Katie - What can you say?
I'd only keep her in for the ratings. Love her or hate her she's bloody good TV.8. Ghazal - I think she's way out of her depth. Like Simon she was very lucky to win her task, and out of those left she is by far the weakest contestant.
Last edited by *Laura* : 11-05-2007 at 15:02
1. Katie
2. Ghazal
3.Naomi
4. Kristina
5. Jadine
6. Lohit
7. Simon
8. Tre
Hmm I seem to be in the minority here.
2. Ghazal
3.Naomi
4. Kristina
5. Jadine
6. Lohit
7. Simon
8. Tre
Hmm I seem to be in the minority here.
It's all about Lohit now.
- - -
Simon (I find him interesting)
- - -
Kristina
Tre (for entertainment, and saying it like it is)
Katie (for good TV)
- - -
Naomi (yawn)
Ghazal (yawn)
- - -
Simon (I find him interesting)
- - -
Kristina
Tre (for entertainment, and saying it like it is)
Katie (for good TV)
- - -
Naomi (yawn)
Ghazal (yawn)
My final eight is ranked purely on how much I like them and want them to progress in the show (plus a touch of fanciablity for some of the females ) rather than on their business skills:
1. Tre
2. Naomi
3. Ghazal
4. Lohit
5. Simon
6. Jadine
7. Katie
8. Kristina
In terms of the 'best' person for the job Kristina would probably come out top...but I can't stand her
) rather than on their business skills:1. Tre
2. Naomi
3. Ghazal
4. Lohit
5. Simon
6. Jadine
7. Katie
8. Kristina
In terms of the 'best' person for the job Kristina would probably come out top...but I can't stand her
2 of 3
