Originally Posted by Alrightmate:
“She has made a few good decisions, and hasn't made any serious cockups like others have.”
I have to disagree with you there. Her first cock-up was when she was given the most important pitch in the doggy cabinet task, and she froze. Luckily for her, Gerri stepped in and saved the day.
More seriously, she was an atrocious PM. She cocked up making the chocolate multiple times, losing a couple of hours each time. She ended up with half the product of the other team. She also overlooked the need for lolly sticks. She wasn't able to control Tre and he ended up playing pool back at the house when the others were working.
For me one of her worst moments was telling Sir Alan that she hadn't run out of product. She clearly had. What's more, she knew she was going to at the time, and slowed down sales to eck it out a bit longer, to avoid the embarrassment of having nothing to sell. So it seems to me this was a blatant, planned lie, and she never got as much stick for it as she deserved.
As it happened, Adam was an even worse PM and somehow managed to make less money despite having more to sell. So she won by £10. If she's lost she'd have been fired.
Since then she's kept mousy-quiet. She was part of the group madness on the French task (eg saying Paul was a good PM when he wasn't; being in favour of cheese). In post-firing interviews Adam has a low opinion of her on the shopping list task.
In my opinion she is the weakest candidate left, by far. don't see how you can compare her with Simon, Naomi or Lohit, all of whom are very good.