Which Josephs would you have liked to have seen in the top five.

In order to get the ball rolling, and in strict order of preference, here are mine

1. Lee
2. Daniel
3. Ben (though if you'd told me in the very beginning that I'd end up having him as number three I'd have eaten that Beanie hat)
4. Seamus
5. Antony

1. Lee
2. Seamus

To be perfectly honest I haven't seen 'Joseph qualities' in any of the other guys.

1. Lee
2. Daniel
3. Seamus
4. Keith
5. Lewis

This is based purely on talent/suitability for the role with the top 4 being the better singers but Lewis creeps in for looking Joseph like - very photogenic.

1. Lee
2. Shaun - who was knocked out before the finals
3. Daniel
4. Craig
5. Chris (was it C anyway the first one eliminated)

1.Keith
2.Chris B
3.Lewis
4.Chris C
5.Lee

1. Lee
2. Daniel
3. Seamus
4. Ben
5. Keith

1. Lee
2. Daniel
3. Ben
4. Craig
5. Keith

seamus/lee
daniel
lewis
thats all.

Daniel (obviously)
Antony (he had something. Loads of charisma, let down by dodgy song, and his own dodgy falsetto. Did one of the best "Close Every Door"s so far)
Chris C (deserved more of chance. Fantastic show voice, wonderful CED)
Keith (I just like him )
Ben (real stage presence)

1 - Daniel
2 - Daniel
3 - Daniel
4 - Daniel
5 - Daniel

Yes!, i know, theres always one!!!!!!!!!

Lee
Daniel
Rob
Ben
Anthony

I've got five I'd like to see do the role...spaced over five years to give them time.
Lee - right now (Heh. I think I'd better Lee right now. I kill myself laughing.) I think he's the only one who's ready to take on the role in just over a month's time.
Seamus - 2008, when people get over that bit of pique at the end of his song. He's got a marvelous presence.
Craig - 2009, with the mentoring of someone like Bill Kenwright. And if anyone had ever said I'd end up backing Craig, they'd have gotten laughed at. He's gotten SO much better, truly learning from what he's seeing rather than just not being as bad as his first performances (coughbencough).
Antony - 2010. He'll be 20 and have experience enough not to crack under pressure. He has tremendous dignity and the beginnings of an amazing voice.
Keith - 2011. He's older than Antony but doesn't look it. He needs to grow into his face and get four years of serious dramatic training. Superb voice.

lee
daniel
keith
anthony
ben

Lee
Daniel
Anthony
Chris B
Lewis

I know very weird choices and even though i have said ALW is right Daniel is not a Joseph I still would have loved him to reach his set goal

1. Lee
2. Keith
3. Craig
4. Antony
5. Seamus

Lee
Seamus
Daniel
Lewis
Keith

Lee
Seamus
Daniel
Chris B
Rob

Daniel
Ben
Chris B
Lewis
Lee

Favourites for Joseph ?

1. Craig

I'm not greedy so
Just the one will do for me

Lee (favourite but maybe too good for Joseph
Daniel (not as suited to the part as Lee, vocally too good for Joseph)
Ben/Seamus (Hard to say, I think I would have liked Seamus more as he went into the competition, and he's more reliable than Ben. But Ben has improved a lot and is a great performer.)
Chris C (his close everydoor to me still sends shivers up my spine!)

1. Lee
2. Daniel
3. Seamus
4. Craig
5. Keith

Finally someone who agrees with me. I could not have put that better myself!

Anyhoo,

My ideal top five at the start of the show would probably have been:

1. Lewis (of course!)
2. Rob (I felt let down by 'Born to Run')
3. Chris B (Again, let down by one or two performances)
4. Antony (No comment)
5. And Seamus, I suppose ("A conspiracy!" )

But I thought it would have been: (as in who would actually still be there now - nothing to do with personal preference)

1. Lee
2. Daniel
3. Keith
4. Johndeep ( I know!)
5. Rob (or possibly Seamus)

Now however, and in answer to the original question () it would have to be:
1. Lewis
2. Craig
3. Daniel
4. Chris B.
5. Ben
(with Rob and Seamus very narrowly missing out on places)

Now, as no-one actually asked for my opinion, I'll just go quietly.....

I only ever liked two and one of them has gone but there oare others i could just about put up with ssooooo my top five are

1.Lee (loved him from the moment i saw him)
2. Daniel (purley cos Lee's better suited to the part although i honestly thought Dan would come 2nd)
3.Ben (due to some progression)
4. Seamus (probs the only other one I would trust)
5. actually didn't like anyone else but if I had to chose a 5th it would be the lad that went 1st Chris C wasn't it??? he sung close everydoor really well I thought

For me it would be:-

1. Daniel
2. Lee
3. Anthony
4. Ben
5. Lewis/Craig

My choices:

1. Daniel
2. Lee
3. Ben
4. Johndeep
5. Keith