Having been to a lot of filmings of things and seen just how many times they reshoot bits and 'set-up' bits that we are led to believe are spontaneous I wouldn't take much notice of what they say in clips like this. They could quite possibly have been asked to say certain things or asked at some point why they are disappointed for not being picked which they would obviously answer... They probably said a lot of things and a few seconds were picked. I don't see how anyone can think any worse of any of the boys based on some edited comments.

thanks for the link marcowil. I have seen him (and others) perform the song. and of course BK does it amazingly. But I just loved saturdays version because of the Lee factor and being pleased for him, and because of the general enthusiasm I have for the show!

I don't know whether it was a set-up by the producers or whether it was genuinely Josh Groban's choice and I have no opinion on this. What I will say though is that I don't think Lee made that great a job of it. He wasn't bad, he was good but not great.

Unfortunately, the decisions of a high number of the viewing public do are affected by this and the producers of this type of show are aware of it.

that's not the only unprofessional thing that Keith did on Saturday night , did anyone notice how he doesn't sing the poor poor joesph and close everydoor with the other save joesphs when someone goes. I've noticed it before but it was really obvious on Sat night. when all you could hear as Lee and Ben's voices singing and they should a shot of keith and he didn;t even bother to open his mouth too sing!
It's not the first time he has done this also did it when Daniel and a couple of the others went, so why do we think he does not bother to sing with the other joesphs at the group bit for poor poor joesph and close every door???

No I've never been aware of that before, but I have noticed some seriously half assed performances from him in the group numbers. It often comes across as if he isn't really concentrating.

oh i just went to see and your right. if he is singing he doesnt open his mouth much.

well yea thats true and a shame. I'm surprised that so many people on these boards get so affected by them tho.

or maybe concentrating too hard? like say on the moves and kinda forgets to sing or visa versa. Maybe it doesn't come as naturally to him due to lack of experience? *goes to off watch saturdays goodbye again*

lol


yeh that's what i have felt almost from the start for me Keith acts like he's just not intrested in the group stuff and its an inconvenience to him, many of you that know me know that i dont like "dissing" the Joesph's but I just think when you're told to do something like that you should actually have the decency to do it.


I am actually going to try and find the other goodebyes see how many he does not bother to sing in

I have noticed that. - i have no idea why he does it though.

there's no excuses for it and to be honest he shouldn't be allowed to get away with it

I have just looked on youtube and have found
Chris C, Daniel, Seamus, Antony,Chris B's and craig's eviction songs (couldn't find the others) and Keith does NOT sing on any of them!!! one maybe i'd let him off but 6 is taking the piss a bit in my opinion and he wont be able to get away with it much longer as like on Saturday it became far to obvious he was not singing

Perhaps he just can't remember the words!

Or perhaps he's acting it through the power of mime

LOL

Keith the new Marcel Marcaeu!

well whatever it is he's doing it's not bloody singing

I could see him singing in Chris B's. Will go and look at the others now.

Doesn't bother me as at least I get to hear more of Lee's lovely voice. His really stood out on Saturday.

lol must havr blinked and missed that one then,

I;m sure he doesn't on the others though!

lol yeh that what i was thinking, was lovely hearing Lee singing it on sat. I only brought the subject up becuse i think its a bit naughty not to sing , not that i;m complaining

He was singing in Craigs as well although it doesn't have a close up of him. He wasn't opening his mouth loads but Lee wasn't either. they were both singing though.

he is not singing on craigs i;m sure of it well maybe Lee was just drowning him out then!

You can only really see him at the beginning and he is singing just not opening his mouth much. Lee is the same at the beginning - I had to look twice to see if he was singing. Its the same on Antonys....can't tell on Seamus' as they don't actually film him at an angle where you can see

it all depends at what angle your looking at then but for 6 eviction songs one that i was at as well he did not sing or at least he's doing a very good job of it with his mouth shut

Ive just rewatched it and noticed during Craig singing CLose every Door - towards the ined when the other Josephs sing "For we know we shall find" You can REALLY hear Lees voice over the others.

I reckon he just doesn't open his mouth very much, you can see him sing if you look really closely

yep Lee stole the show with that one was brill!