Have just booked my tickets so will just have to keep voting for LEE!
Who would you pay to see
4 of 4
i have already bought my tickets (45 in all and half of the party don't watch ADWD). I will be going whatever.
I am hoping to see Lee or Ben but wouldn't mind seeing Lewis or Keith my reasons in order are:-
Lee - a good all rounder can sing act move and very good to look at.
Ben - Has star quality, can act, move and just needs to be more consistent with vocals and i believe he could do this
Lewis - Has something but difficult to put my finger on it and I know there are people in our party that really like him.
Keith - An outstanding voice but needs to work on the acting and movement. The boy can definitely sell a ballad.
I am hoping to see Lee or Ben but wouldn't mind seeing Lewis or Keith my reasons in order are:-
Lee - a good all rounder can sing act move and very good to look at.
Ben - Has star quality, can act, move and just needs to be more consistent with vocals and i believe he could do this
Lewis - Has something but difficult to put my finger on it and I know there are people in our party that really like him.
Keith - An outstanding voice but needs to work on the acting and movement. The boy can definitely sell a ballad.
When I think about it, the only 'Joseph' I'd actually shell out for a trip to London specifically to see Joseph would be Daniel....but if I happened to be going to London on other business, I'd definitely pay to see Lee, Lewis or Keith. If Ben's vocals improved as dramatically as he twists on stage then I might consider him too but on current performance, no.
Originally Posted by ewan wilson:
“When I think about it, the only 'Joseph' I'd actually shell out for a trip to London specifically to see Joseph would be Daniel....but if I happened to be going to London on other business, I'd definitely pay to see Lee, Lewis or Keith. If Ben's vocals improved as dramatically as he twists on stage then I might consider him too but on current performance, no.”
“When I think about it, the only 'Joseph' I'd actually shell out for a trip to London specifically to see Joseph would be Daniel....but if I happened to be going to London on other business, I'd definitely pay to see Lee, Lewis or Keith. If Ben's vocals improved as dramatically as he twists on stage then I might consider him too but on current performance, no.”
We have a new poster on his appreciation thread whose daughter goes to same school and says Ben has never sang flat before ADWD and is amazed by this . I also wonder what this is all about too. A really bad singer and they would not have put him through to the final 12 and he was picked for grease but dropped out in favour of joseph. Surely two programmes wouldn't have got it so wrong
Originally Posted by twingle:
“We have a new poster on his appreciation thread whose daughter goes to same school and says Ben has never sang flat before ADWD and is amazed by this . I also wonder what this is all about too. A really bad singer and they would not have put him through to the final 12 and he was picked for grease but dropped out in favour of joseph. Surely two programmes wouldn't have got it so wrong”
“We have a new poster on his appreciation thread whose daughter goes to same school and says Ben has never sang flat before ADWD and is amazed by this . I also wonder what this is all about too. A really bad singer and they would not have put him through to the final 12 and he was picked for grease but dropped out in favour of joseph. Surely two programmes wouldn't have got it so wrong”
He's not really bad singer, but I'm afraid I'd rather judge him on the basis of what I've heard than what someone whose daughter allegedly goes to his school said about him... in any case, that video link you posted of Nessun Dorma was pretty poor! And I don't want to sound patronising, but there's more to singing well than not 'singing flat' - even if we're just talking about intonation, there's sharp as well as flat, for a start!
Originally Posted by Phil2003:
“He's not really bad singer, but I'm afraid I'd rather judge him on the basis of what I've heard than what someone whose daughter allegedly goes to his school said about him... in any case, that video link you posted of Nessun Dorma was pretty poor! And I don't want to sound patronising, but there's more to singing well than not 'singing flat' - even if we're just talking about intonation, there's sharp as well as flat, for a start!”
“He's not really bad singer, but I'm afraid I'd rather judge him on the basis of what I've heard than what someone whose daughter allegedly goes to his school said about him... in any case, that video link you posted of Nessun Dorma was pretty poor! And I don't want to sound patronising, but there's more to singing well than not 'singing flat' - even if we're just talking about intonation, there's sharp as well as flat, for a start!”
Well Said - i agree
Originally Posted by Phil2003:
“He's not really bad singer, but I'm afraid I'd rather judge him on the basis of what I've heard than what someone whose daughter allegedly goes to his school said about him... in any case, that video link you posted of Nessun Dorma was pretty poor! And I don't want to sound patronising, but there's more to singing well than not 'singing flat' - even if we're just talking about intonation, there's sharp as well as flat, for a start!”
“He's not really bad singer, but I'm afraid I'd rather judge him on the basis of what I've heard than what someone whose daughter allegedly goes to his school said about him... in any case, that video link you posted of Nessun Dorma was pretty poor! And I don't want to sound patronising, but there's more to singing well than not 'singing flat' - even if we're just talking about intonation, there's sharp as well as flat, for a start!”
Phil2003
On your premise they are all in the same boat as all four have had problems with pitch, tuning etc
The majority of the TV viewers will vote on performances they see, not just their favourite (Simon Cowell once said to me that you can put any boy in pants on stage and ????? will scream) and those jumping in on every occasion on each thread to say "I agree" when they see someone knocking one contestant and not their favourite.
Back to the video, it is not that good quality, but my information is not a girl and is from someone over a long period of time, who has been involved with a few of the wannabe Josephs!
BEN can be Joseph!
I would pay to see Lee because he just plain rocks and Lewis because to me he just captres me when he performs and makes me want to watch him whereas some of the others i tend to drift off or talk to my brother...
Originally Posted by jaybs:
“Phil2003
On your premise they are all in the same boat as all four have had problems with pitch, tuning etc”
“Phil2003
On your premise they are all in the same boat as all four have had problems with pitch, tuning etc”
I never said they didn't! But everything in comes in degrees, and I said before, tuning is only part of the picture when it comes to good singing.
4 of 4
