[
I agree

I also would like Lewis to go home not because he's awful and probably he's more of an all rounder than either of the other young ones. Sings well more consistently than Ben (although I find his voice a bit screechy); dances & acts better than Keith. However I just find him the least improved and a bit bland - he's never had a performance when I've thought wow the boy's got "something" - all of the other 3 have.

However I have a horrible feeling he is very popular with the girls and will stay.

Do you really think so? I just have no idea what is going on in that blokes head, but he keeps harping on about wanting a young Joseph so maybe he would save Keith. Doubt that situation would ever arise tho tbh

I think he admires Lee, but I don't know if he sees him as a Joseph!

It's too hard to say, God only knows what goes on in that man's head!

I have to agree that Lewis has never really had a stand out performance. Also at one point in the competition he seemed to be regressing, and that was without having a hard song to sing.

It is going to be such a close one this week
I certainly wouldn;t want to be in the Lord's shoes having to decide who to save and who should go home

I don't know why, but I just can't picture Keith as Joseph for some reason, whereas with the others I can see them doing it
oo I dunno!!!! it's so hard to decide!!

Speak for yourself. I've never cast one vote for either Craig or Keith.

Neither are all rounders.

Craig's not good enough yet although he obviously listens to direction and works hard.

Keith has a good voice and um......nothing else to mark him out as a possible WE star.

I'd be happy to see Keith go.

I'd be devastated if Lee didn't make the final although personally, I think he'd be able to command better lead roles than Joseph and winning would tie him down for 6 months.

If one of the four left can command better roles than Joseph - why have they not done so far?????

Okay this week is a hurdle to climb and I can't predict who will go, but next week it will be a lot different who may reach The Final Two!

Agreed Snips, I don't think his decisions have been at all consistent. I just keep thinking 'Well, what DO you want then?'

To be fair to both Ben and Keith they have only been in full time training 1-2 years. That's what I find so fascinating about the show - the potential of particularly those 2. Whereas Lee is there now I think 1 or both could be the bigger star long term it depends how hard they work. Is it easier to develop a voice or stage presence - I don't have the expertise to comment? One thing for sure I can never see them competing for the same role (they are so opposite) which is ironic that they are now.

I think Lewis and Ben will be in the sing-off. Could possibly be Keith but I still think ALW has a soft spot for him.

If Lewis gets knocked out they'd better have hankies ready, cos there'll be tears before bedtime!!

Sheesh am now starting to want none of them to go.........Couldn't they have 3 Josephs and 1 Benjamin Not saying which one I think should be the latter

We couldn't possibly guess

I think Lewis and Keith will be in the sing-off. ALW has recently been expressing concerns for Keith - e.g making guarded compliments like "he is a great talent with a long way to go". Expect some negative comments from him tomorow night. Lewis I think will be in the sing-off as Ben was saved last week and the pattern seems to be swings and roundabouts.

I think, personally, ALW will save Lewis again. Then as far as the final goes Lee (who has never been in the sing-off) will be up against Ben and Lewis (who by that time will have been saved 3 times each). No prizes for guessing who will win then. I don't mind as I am now supporting Lee since Daniel went.

This is only speculation.

Ben has been at Stage School for the past couple of years, but Keith hasn't. He's attending Telford College in Edinburgh and studying for a HNC in Theatre. The only other experience he's been gaining is by attending StageQuest which is a Theatre Workshop, by no means in the same league as the Italia Conti Stage School.

In comparison to the others he's had the least help and experience before 'Joseph' and in that context I think he's played a blinder so far.

I agree Gilly

But I wish they would stop pushing the supermarket kid made good routine. It is nauseating

I do think though that Ben has had the hardest journey in this show. keith has very seldom had bad comments and never been in a sing off whereas Ben has had to fight right from the off and latterly Lewis

I think the reason Keith has had so much positive feedback lies in the power of his voice. ALW I am sure is looking beyond now and to the future. He can see a star in the making in my opinion.

I've said all along that I support Keith but not because I want him to win this contest. Once he matures both vocally and performance wise I believe he's going to be a force to be reckoned with and will be a West End star.

Ben and Lewis have their strengths, but underneath his seemingly young exterior I feel Keith is the one out of the three of them that does have a strong future.

Not as a Leading Man!

Ben, Keith and Lewis are raw and exciting these are the type that you can shape and develop, they have only been in training so far and doing local theatre work, but they are ready! and can be Joseph!

Says you!

I agree. Lewis is more of a dancer than a singer, im not saying he's talentless he's far from it but his strengh is dancing, could he really handle 8 shows a week with his voice?
As with ben whilst there is no doubt he has the confidence and the right attitude for the part could his voice handle 8 shoes a week and any dodgily high notes that come his way?

Lee and Keith i think perform superior to ben and lewis although neither are without their faults, lee comes across as a bit over prepared sometimes and too polished on occasion and keith can be a tad to smiley and sometimes has difficulty getting round all of the words.

I think it should be ben and lewis in the sing off tho, no offense to them, the other two are just stronger performers.

Speak for yourself.......

I have never and will never vote for anyone based on nationality - and yes, I am a HUGELY patriotic Scot

I would agree that Lee is the strongest and has been from day 1, but Keith needs to prove he can act and move (see the new bit about Keith on BBC website). Show 1 Keith was a huge contender for me because of his powerful voice but he now needs to improve on the other skills. So for me he is in 4th place at the moment. I do feel with more training he could be a star. Ben is a strong performer just needs consistency with vocals so 2nd place for me.

getting to the point................however i agree that Ben and Lewis will probably be in sing-off

I don't want to see any of them go, I haven't done for the last few weeks. But if I had to pick one to go I would say Lewis. Whoever goes this week I hope it's not the last we see of them.

I can't answer this question, too scared I might tempt fate (don't want to be a Jonah! )

Michelle McManus springs to mind here

I'd love to see Lee and Keith in the sing off so we get more of an idea who ALW really wants, that would be an interesting one.

Would prefer Lewis or Ben to be Joseph but not sure Lewis is strong enough emotionally so that leaves Ben.

If it's Lewis and Ben in the sing off, that is going to be a close and tough one. ALW has said he wants a young, poppy Joseph and they surely fit the bill the best, more than Lee or Keith.