i think penny is a better dancer and her scores have proved so except the jive but i think gabby would be better at some dances than penny

Gabby, however Penny has more likeability so I'd prefer to have her in the competition.

I do feel bad for Gabby though.

Definitely Gabby imo

depends on your definition of the 'better' - if you had Gabby's technical ability with Penny's performance you'd have the perfect dancer!!

Technically, probably Gabby. Performance wise, Penny. I also find Penny's movement more grounded than Gabby's, which is a bit too flighty and skippy for me.

If you could have Gabby's technical ability and Penny's performance, you'd have a great dancer! As it stands, I don't think either of them are quite there.

[quote=elizabethjo;18997267]Typical to start a thread slagging off the dancers who find themselves in the bottom two when quite obviously neither of them should have been there.

Just trying to gauge opinion, never slagged anyone off.

[quote=marie67;19004082

Just trying to gauge opinion, never slagged anyone off.[/QUOTE]

Well, marie67, it is obvious from all your other posts that you are an avid Gabby-fan.
Yes, I am also sorry she went this early, but I would've equally been sorry if it had been Penny.

IMO, you did start this thread to dis Penny and to praise Gabby. I'm sorry, but it is how I perceive it and obviously I am not alone.
Last edited by LaChatteGitane : 29-10-2007 at 21:49

I thought Penny was better, but her facial expressions seem odd sometimes. A smile wouldn't go amiss.

Gabby is good, but she needed to feel the music, and get into the vibe a bit more, worry less about the splits and backflips and think about musicality and flow.