Originally Posted by Puffle:
“I have to say I wondered if it was because Mel B was English and to be honest I don't believe the show dance has much to do with the result - we've seen it in the UK time and again, the winner is rarely decided on the showdance, usually what has gone on before.
I personally would prefer Melissa to win, only because I want Tony to win more than Cheryl. Also, I think Melissa did a wonderful job coming in at such short notice and I don't believe previous dance experience should be held against her - speaking from experience I know it's not always as easy as people think to go from one dance discipline to another - especially if you've danced one discipline for years and years and the style and movements are ingrained into your brain - very difficult to retrain yourself and your body to work in a different way.”
I have to disagree about the showdance influencing results - Tom & Camilla
only won scd last year because of their showdance; I think it was the same when Darren Gough won, and Colin James lost it with the ridiculous showdance that Erin had put together for him.
Agree about Melissa. Previous dance experience will certainly be a help in the first few weeks (poise, balance, ability to move to music etc) but by now that advantage will be lost in the need to learn the technique of new dances.
I feel also, the producers were in a difficult position when choosing a last minute replacement celeb. If they had chosen someone who had never danced anything before, then that person would almost definitely have been first out with only a couple of days to learn a dance.
I'd like Melissa to win (I too like Tony!!!) but wouldn't be upset if Gilles wins. But I might be if Shawn/Ty won!!!!