wth? im still a bit peeved with Arlene saying it was the closest to Jill's jive or whatever she said.

Kelly's was alright, good in parts, but it didnt leave me excited or in awe, as Jill's did. it was a bit meh to me and left me feeling underwhelmed, something was missing for me...

Jill's was brilliant and still is one of my fav dances ever!

Jill's final Jive:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVxxG2AVOCQ

Jill's week 3 Jive:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gENwlVjhUdM

totally agree, there is no way it was as good as jill and darren's

kelly jive was absolutely not at all anywhere near the same league as Jill was

Jill is in a league all of her own and kelly is no where near it!!!

Arlene is obviosuly smoking some of the same stuff as Len is this evening!

hahaha yeh

I'm starting to want Kelly to win just to piss off all the haters.

I dont hate kelly

Just stating my opinion that I dont think she is any where near the standard of Jill Halfpenny

eh I'm not a hater at all, i like her (although her laugh is annoying) and think she's a good dancer, her dances are normally in my top 3 on saturdays, but no way was that dance tonight anywhere near as good as Jill's brilliant jive. no way.

I thought the jive tonight was great.

I like Kelly, although her nervous giggling is starting to grate.

By the end of the competition, given a bit more time, who knows how good it would be?

Kelly's great across both disciplines, just like Alesha is.

Jive was not great, not much bounce. Didn't match Alesha and far below Jill's standard.

It was good but it wasnt great.

Only someone who really doesn't like Kelly/Brendan would start a thread like this imo.

Watch arlenes comment back...

she said it was the closet anyone had come....

maybe not been so blasted mean eh? she was the only female celeb who had kept up with such hard timing and had a great leg action.

Der Chef says

In all due fairness I thought it was a nice fast routine and extremely good by this years standards

However it seems Kelly and Alesha have been given 9 and 10's for being the two alpha females and turing up neither has really given us a wow dance this year and I dont care what hyperbole the fab 4 use they simply haven't.

Ohhh yeah

Kelly and Brendan were great. However Jill Halfpenny's jive was my favourite SCD dance ever (despite the fact that I am more of a ballroom fan) and that view hasn't changed tonight

Very well said

Alesha and Matt's if your going to compare was the nearest at a push to jill's Jive.

Kelly's jive was FLAT!!!

True! Kelly can only dream of being in Jill halfpenny's league.

excuse me?
i already stated they nearly always come in my top 3 on performance night. i would have made it regardless of whichever couple it was because i was a massive fan of jill's dancing, not because i hate kelly.

I thought Kelly and Brendans Jive was the best dance tonight, with Alesha and Matt a very close second.

Arlene might say it was closest to Jill but her score didn't match it so why are some people here still not happy about it? I think Kelly and Brendan were severlly undermarked tonight, they should get at least 2 10s, if not 4.

I am in full agreement with all of these comments that Kelly's jive matched Jill Halfpenny. No way was this so, Kelly is a good dancer, but not in the same league as Jill or Alesha.

No way! Matt & Alesha wiped the floor with Brendan & Kelly!!!

Not wow for you - for me, Alesha's jive was near wow factor, and her foxtrot moved me to tears.

Talking of other wow dances, I thought Gethin should have been clear first at the top of the leaderboard last week.

It's partly in the eye of the beholder.

I am happy someone done a thread like this because I agree, no were near Jill and Darren.

Yeah right Kellys jive was in the same league as Jill and Darrens! She wishes, nothings come close to that jive in all the previous series.
I bet it wouldnt have even been compared or the two dances wouldnt even have been mentioned alongside each other if Kelly hadnt been hyping it up herself.