len 9/10 the only one who realises the celebs were not dancers 10 weeks ago
craig 6/10 the sooner he realises it's not a competition the better. if it was acomp the phone lines would only be open on the night of the dances
arlene 1/10 should not be on this show
bruno [minus 10/10 this guy is a total wally & i'm being polite
Last edited by hibbychubbs : 08-12-2007 at 21:36

Craig 9/10 Genuine and does not get personal. perhaps a tad harsh tonight.
Arlene 8/10 Much improved tonight and with fewer cliched remarks. What she had to say was very positive.
Bruno 6/10 A nice guy and quite entertaining but DWTS has made him more OTT.
Len 4/10 Just occasionally shows that he still knows how to do it. Inconsistent and far too personal when it comes to fellow judges as well as some celebs and pro dancers.

I'd happily do the same!

As for scoring the judges, basing it on the past two series of SCD (the only ones I've seen):

Craig - 8 (fast becoming the only judge worth listening to)
Arlene - 6 (I often agree with her, but she's too inconsistent, and some of her remarks and alliterations are atrocious)
Bruno - 3 (a fool, whose over-marking of just about everyone de-values the show)
Len - 2 (ditto, only less likeable than the above, in fact lately he's been just plain rude).

I liked the way Bruno treated Matt when he spoke to him. Len was OK too until he started arguing with Craig.
Arlene was reasonably short and to the point, but her voice was at it's most painful.
Craig? Well I rate Craig as the most consistent judge and he was consistent again. His criticism was honest and constructive. In the circumstances, I think he should have cut it to a bare minimum. Flavia knows more about ballroom dancing than Craig Arlene and Bruno put together, so it's not as if Matt actually needs the advice.
I think Len and Bruno should not have given Matt such high marks, but they, (and Arlene to a lesser extent) seem to be plucking them out of the air this year.

Craig 9 - honest and consistent

Arlene 6 - too much of the silly alliteration

Len 2 - lost the plot

Bruno 3 - entertaining but pointless

Bruno just gives basically the same mark as Len unless he loses his head over Alesha.

My mum is convinced that Bruno is Len's boyfriend and gets told in an undertone what to mark! Although neither she or I obviously have any evidence for this

Craig 9/10 - consistent, honest, hard but fair, tries to add something positive, gives tens only for very special performances. Sometimes a little bit too personal.
Arlene 8/10 - we could do without the cringeworthy alliteration and the drewling over 20 year old boys, but apart from that I generally like what she has to say.
Bruno 5/10 - like him as an OTT personality, but his marking is also OTT and inconsistent and his favouritism is annoying.
Len 1/10 - rude, vulgar, bloated ego, ridiculous marking, unprofessional to the other judges, hypocritical, an embarrassment to the series.