Originally Posted by SGE:
“Yes, I absolutely agree (Rhydian wouldn't really have been suited to that role), but surely Barrowman et al are looking at what's happening now and wondering if only they had done something, I don't know what, but something, you know?”
But then again X-Factor were so close to letting Rhydian go as well - I mean Danni said no to him in his first audition and he was close to not making it into the live shows. I think Rhydian's one of those people who you have to see doing the right song to be able to fully appreciate him, yknow, and after all those Joseph auditions Rhyd probably done a naff song (like his first XF auditon) and John Barrowman etc just didn't think twice.