Apologies in advance for starting yet another thread.

I cant help but feel stupid when my threads dissapear off the 1st page without trace, I just like to think people wont forget about certain contestants.

Im already preparing myself for the worst.

Steph hands down is the better sing

Steph was only excluded on age, when it comes down to it.

She is probably a better singer than Phoebe, but Phoebe has the rep for being the best in a group - like Robbie Williams or Suzanna Hoffs.

Next year perhaps Steph will be allowed through.

I do hope Steph comes back next year, even though she has set up her own site, final 12 definitely if the show/format is still around.

I think Steph has got a deal. She'd have got through if she had any other mentor

One thing that this forum agrees on is that Steph should have made he final four. For me I'd say both and together Sharon could have had a strong chance of winning.

I like Phoebe, something in her voice was just likeable. I just wish she could have gone in as a soloist.

It does make you wonder why Phoebe didnt get in the final 3, she was way better than Lady Shiverz.

It takes me back to an earlier conspiracy theory that the idea of putting a group together was thought of before.

i think Phoebe on her own was laking something, which i think the other 4 members of Hope made up .......

Perhaps your right, i think Raquelles definitely got an important place in the group.

definatley, i think Hope need Raquelle

Imagine a girl group with steph, phoebe and paris, would it work?

Steph

Raquelle can't sing. Phoebe is alright but not that great.

Exactly. Steph was good. Phoebe overated and Raquel

Does everyone one think Steph will have a deal by x-factor next year?