This just isn't working. Someone makes a suggestion, a few people agree, a few people disagree, a new suggestion is made.
We're going round in circles. We need a more methodical way to work out who the next Doctor should be.
And this is it...
Everyone should write the names of everyone they
don't want to be the Doctor. There's no debating the names people put down. If someone doesn't like that person then they're no good as the Doctor.
So we'll do that for a week or so, giving those people who only enter the forum after an episode has aired a chance to cast their anti-vote.
Then, on January 1st we can take all the rejects out of the equation and whoever is left is our perfect Doctor! Can't go wrong.*
* Yes, I'm aware of the minor flaw in this plan. What if there is more than one person in the world who is left after the rejects have been counted? Easy, we'll pick the middle one - sure to be the safe bet.