I agree with Randy Jackson. Of all the songs from the 70s, she picks the most random shit!

I really don't like Kristy. The fact that in the past she was signed to the label that Idol winners sign to doesn't help either.

Singing 'You're no good'
The way she pronounced 'you're' as 'yer' bugged me to no end

OH YAY, Its Frankenstein

She actually looks quite pretty without that stupid big hair and coal miner eyes!

Edit: OMG, WTF has she done with her hair?!?!?!?!?!?!?!!?

She looks more and more like Pepe le Pew every week

Wish she was a decent singer though

AAAAAAAARRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!! This is just so awful on so many counts!

She's a gonner.

My poor ears.

'Way too much melody'
That was pretty painful for my ears, I think she could be gone this week

I thought Amanda was a little better this week than last (not saying much), but when she sings she still sounds like she's been on the beer to me. She was also getting a bit too much assistance from the backing vocalists at times, too. No idea what the song was, which didn't help.

The judges were pretty much gunning for her, so I think she's gone. I can live with that.

I thought that was the second best just behind Carly.

ARGH - I just wanna' shake Amanda - I know she's a good singer but my god does she not choose the right songs.

I like how she doesn't give a $hit though. Hopefully if she's in next week she will do a more bluesy number.
She was brilliant at Travellin' Band - I want that Amanda back.

Brooke is the best so far, Carly a close 2nd.

WTF is Alexandrea Lushington wearing?

Not liking this rendition of "baby please dont go"

Another weird song choice.

I thought it was just my age showing!

She seems to wear her hair likes she's developing male pattern baldness too.

Here's 'ole dead shark eyes

Really iffy start

This isn't happening at all.

^ I wish this wasn't! ^

Oooooo, strong finish from Asia

How can they say it was good, it was diabolical, and the vocal acrobatics didnt save herrr

It was really poor tonight, the only performances I liked were Brooke's and Carly's

Well it ain't my fault if everyone else has gone quiet. Supposed to be a live comment thread, innit? ;P

Shame it's a bit quiet in here compared to the X Factor live threads.