That was bad

NOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Sorry , I was making a live comment, I meant Asia's performance!

Poor night for the girls, overall

Brooke - Definitely still my favourite. She has a richness in her voice I really like.
Syesha - pretty good I thought. I thought the judges were a bit harsh.
Asia - Strong finish, good in parts, more than a tad iffy in others - if she could sort that out, I think she could be really good.
Ramiele - good singer, I'd agree with the judges though, bit a iffy song choice.
Alaina - pretty good, but I don't know. I just don't like her voice, it has a harshness to it.

Rest of them were all a bit poor, with dodgy song choices.

Oh, right. No probs.

Carly and Alaina were the best in myy opinion.

Does anyone else find the other Jason (with dreadlocks) slightly disturbing to look at? He's got a bit of a manic stare.

Just a big bit yes

WTF!!!!!!!!!!

Poor Alex

Amanda survives again. Still, not a total shock that Alex went, she was poor on the night. Shame.

She's gutted, poor thing. So she should be losing to Amanda (I'm being restrained here).

Does anyone else think that was actually good this time round?

I thought she was worse because you could hear the emotion in her voice which made her waver on and off key. I didn't think she was too bad on the night ... not great but much better than Amanda.

Not overly upset Alexandréa went out. She wasnt one of my favourites at all.

Presuming the second row of girls are Kady, Syesha, Carly, Ramiele and Alaina, who do you think might go?

I think Carly and Ramiele are safe, but it could be any of the other 3, in which case, i'd like Kady to go.

I also think Luke will deservedly be eliminated next

Yay Syesha

Aww

Aaaaaaaaawwwwwwwww

Oh my embarrasing moment or what?

OH MY GOD

That was one of the most emotional exits for me.

She's only 17, I don't think it's embarrassing at all. I've always thought it's incredibly cruel to get them to sing seconds after being told their dream has ended.

Well, they gave her the choice whether to sing or not, and credit to her, she held it together alot better than I thought she would have.

It's got to be Luke, surely? He was dreadful.

WTF is America thinking?

That should've been Luke going he was the worst of the night

Should have been Kady and Amanda tonight.