The top 12 :

David Archuleta
David Cook
David Hernandez
Micheal Lee Johns
Chikezie Eze
Jason Castro
Carly Smithson
Kristy Lee Cook
Syesha Mercado
Brooke White
Amanda Overmyer
Ramiele Malubay


Eliminated :

Luke Menard
Danny Noriega
Kady Malloy
Asia'h Epperson




Can't say I'm surprised at any of the eliminations.

Very happy with that but would have liked Kristy to go over Asia'h but still makes no diffrence to me as David Cook is my fav.

Asia'h is the only one I am a little surprised at, I thought Kristy or Amanda would go instead. I am quite pleased with the results though.

I am sad to see Danny Noriega go :[
I will no longer watch AI as he was my favourite.

gutted for Kady although not surprised
i kind of knew Asia'h would go as the "shocker"

All the acts that I thought should be in the final are in it so I am happy with that.

I think David A or Kristy will be first out of the top 12.

Generally happy, I'm preferring the boys this year, and the four I wanted through are all there, so I'm happy

David A? I am not a fan but no way he will be out next.. David H may be

Oh yeah , oops. I meant David H. There's so many Davids it's a bit confusing

I was surprised that Amanda didn't go and would have preferred Danny over Chickezie...but overall I'm happy with the top 12.

Glad Danny and Kady have gone

Well done Carly.I'm sure she'll get to final 5(at least) even if there's 2 or 3 more stronger guys this season.

Chikezie or Kristy Lee will probably be the first ones out.

I'm actually relieved Asia'h is out.. simply because I don't think she's that good and probably would've been overpimped if she made it to the finals.

Yeah I liked Asia'h to although last week, she wasn't as good as she had been previous. Generally a good solid top 12 though. I think this is David Archuleta's to lose I'll be happy when there is one David won't have to type full name then. His nearest contender has to be Brooke.

As predicted two of the girls( A'siah and Kady) were voted off. Of course they could not vote off the two that I grouped together. Am happy about Syesha staying as she has potential and is one of my favourites.

The boys were almost correct. Did not think that Danny would go yet because of the teen vote. But who knows if they just got rid of him anyway because they did not want anymore scandals.

Just my theory.

Babeth

If it was a UK show, I would say David H will go next. But as it it a US show, I don't know. The idol forum poll shows Chikezie with the least votes.

If it was a UK show Kristy would be the first to go because she's the weakest singer and the British public as a whole don't seem to like country music as much as America.

I loved Danny and kady

yayyy jason made it. !.

There are lots of Davids in there

All my main favourites made it so I'm happy! I liked Kady as well though, oh well.

I'm a bit surprised at Danny, I thought VFTW were backing him like they did with Sanjaya last year. Unfortunately their other pick, Amanda, did get through; at least Danny could actually sing!

I'm a little surprised at Asia'h too, I didn't think she was actually one of the stronger contestants or anything, but she did seem to have a lot of support at the earlier stages so that's why I'm surprised. I didn't think she was that good anyway.

Great to see Michael and David C through, all the right guys went through, but i would have put Kady and Asiah through over Amanda and Kristy.

I think Kristy will be out first next week.

I am so sad at Danny going - was definately my fav - loved the baby queen moves