***Top 12 Week- Performance and Results Shows- Discussion Thread*** - Page 2

Results:What was your favourite performance?

Syesha Mercado

2 (1.87%)

Ramiele Malubay

3 (2.80%)

Michael Johns

5 (4.67%)

Kristy Lee Cook

0 (0%)

Jason Castro

5 (4.67%)

David Hernandez

2 (1.87%)

David Cook

32 (29.91%)

David Archuleta

3 (2.80%)

Chikezie Eze

29 (27.10%)

Carly Smithson

14 (13.08%)

Brooke White

10 (9.35%)

Amanda Overmyer

2 (1.87%)

Voters: 107. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?

***Top 12 Week- Performance and Results Shows- Discussion Thread***

2 of 6

Hogs Head

13-03-2008

I really liked Ramiele! Gorgeous voice.

claire2281

13-03-2008

I love the way that when Paula says 'you look lovely tonight' it's turned into a slap in the face because you just know she didn't like it.

Velma

13-03-2008

Ramiele sang it sweetly, but it was boring...

tamasooz

13-03-2008

Chikeze was on fire! Totally original twist on the song!

Ramiele - i have to agree with the judges, it was a beautiful song, but it didn't hold my attention for very long!

claire2281

13-03-2008

I rather liked that from Jason. Really nice although I can see what the judges are saying.

Velma

13-03-2008

That was nice from Jason. Randy talks poo!

tamasooz

13-03-2008

If I Fell is one of my favourite Beatle Songs.... and I really liked Jason's performance! Has got me singing along!

What's going on with Simon and Ryan!!!??

Tina_UK

13-03-2008

Jason and David C were my favs.
Chikezie was good too lol he really surprised me

claire2281

13-03-2008

Really great from Carly. I really love the style of what she does.

Velma

13-03-2008

I loved that from Carly (I'm a little bit scared of her...)

claire2281

13-03-2008

Great from David C. I loved that he made it rather sinister.

I'm impressed with the ones who've been confident on stage so far (Chikezie, Carly, Jason and David C).

T--J

13-03-2008

Forgot all about it so I'm watching on ITV+1 and how fab was Chikezie?

T--J

13-03-2008

Jason was baaad this week.

tamasooz

13-03-2008

David C and Carly were pretty amazing! Lots of guys stepping it up this week.

Can't be bothered to watch the second half, know what happens, enjoy!

T--J

13-03-2008

Great performance from Carly.
Don't normally like David C but really enjoyed his performance this week. (Oo-er!

)

Switching back to ITV1 now.

T--J

13-03-2008

Don't think Brooke is up to par this week.

Hogs Head

13-03-2008

Brooke or Carly so far this week, I'm absolutely LOVIN' ~ Brooke has gone up in my rankings!

T--J

13-03-2008

Pah!

It's not nitch, it's niche.

Velma

13-03-2008

I love Brooke, she is so sweet.
She vaguely reminds me (in looks, not voice) of Lena Zavaroni! Am I mad?

claire2281

13-03-2008

Brilliant stuff from Brooke. So glad they've allowed them to use instruments this year.

gillypanda

13-03-2008

I don't like this David H. I really dislike the "why sing one note when 27 will do just as well" style of singing.

T--J

13-03-2008

David H - mostly good but a few dodgy bits when he had to sing softer.

claire2281

13-03-2008

I think David H has a really great voice but that wasn't good. He tried to do too much.

gillypanda

13-03-2008

Originally Posted by Velma:
“I love Brooke, she is so sweet.
She vaguely reminds me (in looks, not voice) of Lena Zavaroni! Am I mad?”

No you're right and you're showing our age!!

Velma

13-03-2008

I saw her Standing There is not an American Idol song, it's too simple, so comes off as karaoke or just plain crap.

2 of 6