***Top 12 Week- Performance and Results Shows- Discussion Thread*** - Page 3

Results:What was your favourite performance?

Syesha Mercado

2 (1.87%)

Ramiele Malubay

3 (2.80%)

Michael Johns

5 (4.67%)

Kristy Lee Cook

0 (0%)

Jason Castro

5 (4.67%)

David Hernandez

2 (1.87%)

David Cook

32 (29.91%)

David Archuleta

3 (2.80%)

Chikezie Eze

29 (27.10%)

Carly Smithson

14 (13.08%)

Brooke White

10 (9.35%)

Amanda Overmyer

2 (1.87%)

Voters: 107. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?

***Top 12 Week- Performance and Results Shows- Discussion Thread***

3 of 6

Velma

13-03-2008

Amanda rocked! I love the tone of her voice even though I can't understand a single word she sings!
She reminds me (in looks, not voice!) of a young Roseanne Barr. I am mad! I would love to be able to wear those kind of trousers she enjoys wearing...

claire2281

13-03-2008

Great stuff from Amanda. Loved what she did with it. And it's good to have her amongst all the 'nice' singers.

T--J

13-03-2008

Love this song and like his voice but the two just don't go well IMO ... I'd probably love it if I hadn't heard the original though.

claire2281

13-03-2008

Michael was okay but I still don't think he's really lived up to his potential.

T--J

13-03-2008

I think Amanda's just a joke contestant!

She was better this week though and she looks sooooooooo much better without all that slap and big hair.

Velma

13-03-2008

Yeeeee Haawww!

claire2281

13-03-2008

Did they speed up that recording?

My name is URL

13-03-2008

that last girl was terrible - last week she was told it was country and good

so now she does country - it's not country idol

...really bad

babeth

13-03-2008

Originally Posted by claire2281:
“Did they speed up that recording?”

Thanks you Claire this is what I thought exactly!! It was not too bad its just the band ran too quickly maybe intentionally.

I still liked Michaels offer. He connected with the song for me.

Babeth

Nic H

13-03-2008

Whats with the annoying ad breaks after every single performance!!???

gillypanda

13-03-2008

Originally Posted by Nic H:
“Whats with the annoying ad breaks after every single performance!!??? ”

Particularly the Chicago Pizza ads

I really, really hate them

Nic H

13-03-2008

How old is this guy?? 8 ??

My name is URL

13-03-2008

hi I'm 14 and never heard of the beatles

gillypanda

13-03-2008

Didn't he just forget the words?

My name is URL

13-03-2008

def the first half 'acts' were better - the last load have been dire

the winner is in the first half for me - the rest mediocre

brooke for the win - she is cute and is the only name I remember!

T--J

13-03-2008

Oooo, that was a bit rough from young David.

PamelaL

13-03-2008

Originally Posted by gillypanda:
“Didn't he just forget the words? ”

More than once I think.

Nic H

13-03-2008

No I mean is he 8 as in he looks 8, not because of what he said. Looks like he should be in Junior American Idol. He just doesn't fit it, sorry.

Velma

13-03-2008

Oh dear... This guy is too little and cute to sing this song. I would have preferred Chickeze to sing this rather than Archie David.

claire2281

13-03-2008

Golden boy crashes and burns! I wonder if he can cope with such a big venue?

In a way I'm kind of glad he got poor feedback because I was fed up of the pimping when there are so many other equally, if not more talented, people in the show.

My name is URL

13-03-2008

Originally Posted by PamelaL:
“More than once I think. ”

I can't believe you think even once

PamelaL

13-03-2008

Originally Posted by My name is URL:
“I can't believe you think even once ”

Watch it you.

T--J

13-03-2008

Chikezie was the outright winner for me this week. Bottom 2 would be Amanda and Jason.

PamelaL

13-03-2008

Originally Posted by T--J:
“Chikezie was the outright winner for me this week. Bottom 2 would be Amanda and Jason.”

I loved Chikezie the best tonight. I really like Michael Johns too but then I like James Blunt so don't go by me.

Velma

13-03-2008

I voted Chickezie, but Brooke and Amanda come very close too.

3 of 6