Originally Posted by tinkerbell100:
“As yes and that hockey skating clearly gave Greg an advantage as well didn't it... oh no.. hang on a second, Greg was rubbish! (not that I don't love him - his leaping around the ice was truly magnificent entertainment!)”
Originally Posted by
tinkerbell100:
“I suppose that's my point really, the ease on the ice didn't give him that much of an advantage because there are so many elements that go in to the final product. Chris has managed to combine the lot, not that I think he's perfect. I agree with Jason's comments last week, it wasn't flawless, and it could be better. All that said I just think he looks good on the ice, I enjoy watching him
”
Perhaps the word "advantage" is ambiguous or confusing, because it can seem that skating experience didn't give Greg much of an advantage, because when everything's added up, he didn't come out ahead.
But think of ... a boat race. If someone's given a head start, isn't that an (unfair) advantage, even if their boat turns out not to be as good as some of the others, and they aren't as good at sailing, and so they lose the race?
I think Greg was helped a lot by his skating experience. Just think of how much trouble the ones without such experience had with the required jump -- not only with the jump itself but also with nervousness about having to do it. Some of the performances were unusually shaky that week, and none of them put jumps into their other routines.
I also think Greg wouldn't have lasted as long as he did (or been as entertaining!) if his skating ability had been much less.