ahhh, I think you've just nailed who he reminds me of

No no no! Stop trying to put me off him

(I don't know who Norman Reedus is though.)

well they are both HOT!

Ahh ok just googled him and he is quite beautiful - I think the name Norman was deceiving. There can't be many hot Normans in the world.

Guy - Michael (I also liked Luke)

Girl - Brooke



I agree about the Jack Black thing and David Cook must be the only guy who does "clicheed fake rocker" better than Tenacious D and Spinal Tap.

I don't think he looks like Duncan James at all. In David C's dreams .....................

I really like Jason Castro, he has the most gorgeous eyes & smile.

Michael and Brooke

Maybe a Spitting Image version? but I agree, Duncan James is much more handsome. As for the rest, I think Michael is the best looking by a long way, but his vocals are not as inspiring as his looks.

For me the most atractive Female contestant is Kristy, followed by Amanda then Carly.

Clearly it's tie. A three-way between Kristy, Syesha and Brook.

Actually...

Michael

Brooke / Carly

Are you kidding? He looks like a young Jim McDonald.

I don't see any of them as attractive, but they are all at least somewhat good looking, some are handsome and beautiful as well.

male - has to be David Cook.. he's gorgeous!!!!! and mega talented.

female- brooke i guess ( hoping she wont win though)

Michael Johns. No contest.

I think Michael's voice is every bit as good as his looks. It's a shame that he's being stitched up with the songs and the staging (why is he being denied a mic stand for a start on songs that would be far more suited to performing with one?).

I don't think any of the other guys left are particularly attractive with the least attractive being David C. Luke was, as was the beautiful boy who went out in the first week but whose name I can't remember, and Chikezie is cute.

Out of the girls, I'd say Brooke is the prettiest, followed by Carly and Syesha. I thought Amanda, Amy and Kady were pretty too.

I don't see any appeal in Kristy-Lee. Very plain and ratty-featured.

Meow!

I agree with you. At the audition stage it was Michael Johns who I had my eye on but since the live performances started its definitely David Cook for me. He has something about him which is very attractive.

Michael Johns and Brooke White or Carly Smithson.

David Cooook! Got such a soft spot for him, he reminds me of Chris Daughtry more and more every week.

Whoever said he looks like Jack Black, even better

Lol yep all very hot dudes, the first live week when he sang 'Happy Together' (top 24) I was getting a Patrick Stump sort of vibe from him, lil chubby buy veerrrrrrrrrrry attractive...its amazing how much I don't see that anymore! He looks vastly different almost every week...(but every look works for him ) think it's the ever-changing head hair/facial hair that does it

I think out of the girls, Carly is really pretty - even with that dodgy tattoo!
And the boys...Michael Johns gets the "grrrr!" vote from me but I think Jason is so cute, love his eyes and smile!

Of the boys - it's all about the Cook. However I am a bit of a sucker for smile and eyes of Jason... oh, and the hair.

I think Brooke is the prettiest of the girls now, I dod think that Amanda was stunning when she stopped wearing so much make-up though.

Jason Castro for me.

I say Michael Johns and Brooke White