Your Top 11 Voting + Your Top 12 Results

2 of 2

cotton cloth

17-03-2008

10 Kristy Lee Cook
09 Syesha Mercado
08 Brooke White
07 Carly Smithson
06 Amanda Overmyer
05 David Archuleta
04 Michael Johns
03 David Cook
02 Chikezie Eze
01 Jason Castro
00 Ramiele Malubay

It's still too early to have any really strong opinions yet, everyone's so good this year, so I've rated the women on looks and the guys half on talent and half on how annoying they might become.

toastyred

18-03-2008

10. Carly Smithson
9. Amanda Overmyer
8. Jason Castro
7.Michael Johns
6.Brooke White
5.Ramiele Malubay
4.Syesha Mercado
3.Kristy Lee Cook
2.David Archuleta
1.David Cook
0.Chikezie Eze

Wow, I'm finding it really hard to rank them this year cos I think they're all quite good.

Chi

18-03-2008

10 David Cook
9 Brooke White
8 Jason Castro
7 Michael Johns
6 Carly Smithson
5 Chikezie Eze
4 David Archuleta
3 Syesha Mercado
2 Amanda Overmyer
1 Ramiele Malubay
0 Kristy Lee Cook

hitnmix

18-03-2008

10 - David Cook
9 - Brooke White
8 - Michael Johns
7 - Jason Castro
6 - Carly Smithson
5 - Chikezie Eze
4 - Syesha Mercado
3 - David Archuleta
2 - Amanda Overmyer
1 - Ramiele Malubay
0 - Kristy Lee Cook

InDee

18-03-2008

10 David Cook
9 Jason Castro
8 Michael Johns
7 Carly Smithson
6 Syesha Mercado
5 David Archuleta
4 Amanda Overmyer
3 Ramiele Malubay
2 Brooke White
1 Chikezie Eze
0 Kristy Lee Cook

razorboy

18-03-2008

10 Chikezie Eze
9 Brooke White
8 Jason Castro
7 Ramiele Malubay
6 David Archuleta
5 Syesha Mercado
4 David Cook
3 Amanda Overmyer
2 Michael Johns
1 Carly Smithson
0 Kristy Lee Cook

pinkfish

18-03-2008

10 Jason Castro
9 David Cook
8 Brooke White
7 Michael Johns
6 Carly Smithson
5 Kristy Lee Cook
4 Chikezie Eze
3 David Archuleta
2 Ramiele Malubay
1 Amanda Overmyer
0 Syesha Mercado

Locomo

21-03-2008

10 - David Cook
9 - Syesha Mercado
8 - David Archuleta
7 - Jason Castro
6 - Amanda Overmyer
5 - Chikezie Eze
4 - Micheal Lee Johns
3 - Ramiele Malubay
2 - Kristy Lee Cook
1- Carly Smithson
0 --Brooke White

Locomo

21-03-2008

Originally Posted by cotton cloth:
“It's still too early to have any really strong opinions yet, everyone's so good this year, so I've rated the women on looks and the guys half on talent and half on how annoying they might become.”

I thought your list was rather unusual - until I read this bit. I'm amused.

angelofthenight

21-03-2008

10 - David Cook
9 - Brooke White
8 - Michael Johns
7 - Carly Smithson
6 - Syesha Mercado
5 - Chikezie Eze
4 - Jason Castro
3 - Amanda Overmyer
2 - David Archuleta
1 - Ramiele Malubay
0 - Kristy Lee Cook

2 of 2