This is the thread to talk about the Top 11 shows this week.

The Top 11 are:
Amanda Overmyer
Brooke White
Carly Smithson
Chikezie Eze
David Archuleta
David Cook
Jason Castro
Kristy Lee Cook
Michael Johns
Ramiele Malubay
Syesha Mercado

Theme
Beatles Week Again.

UK Air Times on ITV2:
Thu 20th March: 20.00-21.00: Performances; part 1
Thu 20th March : 22.00-23.00: Performances; part 2
Fri 21st March : 21.00-22.00: Results

Repeats
Sat 22nd March: 11.10-14:10: Performances and Results
Sun 23rd March: 07.50-08.50: Only Results
Sun 23rd March: 18.00-21.00: Performances and Results

good luck Brooke

I'm really nervous for David A!...lol...hope he can pull it together.
And I'll really be glad to get to a new theme next week!
Wonder if the contestants are a bit miffed at having Beatles again...it could have been a factor in which song they chose to sing last week vs. this week.
Should be interesting!

Am sure there would some contestants among them such as Syesha my favourite, Kristy, Rameille, perhaps Chikeze who are equally miffed and worried that the theme weighs heavily against them.

I would not worry if I were them I would sell my personality instead. As for David A. poor sod, he will be fine. He is the Pet this year of AI.

Regards

Babeth

spoiler as to who is performing this week on the results show

Beatles week again?? wasnt last weeks show bad enough lol. looking forward to david cook, michael, jason and brooke sing.

They cant be doing another Beatles Week.

They have many other themes they can do without having to repeat a week.

they said they had postive feedback after last weeks show that they decided to do Beatles again

Just watched the show and it was ok. Only one stand out performance in my opinion:





Personally, I think the same genre two weeks in a row is bizarre and somewhat boring....

I found his performance way to syrupey just found it grating.

IMO not one stand out this week. Very dreary and boring. :yawn:

Yeah my husband thought that too. But I really like that song and it was a good job of it...

That's the thing i love that song too just not the way he sung it. Oh well to each their own hey. Glad someone agrees with me though. LOL

I agree about the first sentence, but

Well by the looks of some of the reviews of this week I dont think they will get as many postive feedback this week.

agreed ^ it defo was wrong to do the same theme twice it just didnt work

next weeks theme however is

Now that should be a good week.

Is it just me? I can't get into the Brooke love at all. I thought Let it Be was okay, nothing special, a bit strained and breathy. Here comes the sun was frankly embarassing. Worst performance of the night. Everyone seems to love her though. I mean, seriously, if she was fat and ugly, would anyone give her the time of day?

I'm not trying to be a bitch, she seems like a really nice girl, but I just don't get it

Agree it was one of the better ones but not that memorable really.

Not my favourite from , but still the only performance that I enjoyed.

I really liked Your So Vain, and Let it Be was good. The studio version is even better. Her voice makes a nice change from the high pitch of most of the other girls.
And LOL, nothing to do with her looks.
It's down to how much you like a voice, and it is very personal. Archie is good, but de does nothing for me at all.

Brooke's performance was definitely her worst, I found it contrived and almost as if she was trying to hard. The so obviously put-on smiles and dropping her head to one side was very cheesy. The singing was very so-so too.

sorry that was a rumour, its actually

Hey is this tonight's thread?

Hi everyone

Aww - Paul, all young and trouble free!

Dire.

Sound overpowering them tonight - even Amanda.