Originally Posted by donovan gracie:
“What was so great about him exactly the fact that he took joy in expressing his gayness to america? there are more gays on american tv than here ppl like him are nothing special. Thats why he was dismissed accordingly”
Quite on the contrary what we talked about is the essence of the show itself, whether it will be an interesting show or not regardless the talent.
and i agree with mark that 'pop' will not appeal to American audience as much as others unless the contestant is a genius who can turn 'genie in the bottle' into something worth an 'american idol standard'.