• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • I'd Do Anything
Who is your favourite Nancy?
<<
<
2 of 5
>>
>
tigger_lily
23-03-2008
Jessie
Loueez
23-03-2008
I liked Nancy... and she's already gone

Shows how much I know!
bigbazzer
23-03-2008
Wow! What a show and how emotional for all the girls involved!
Jodie is by miles the best fit to play Nancy! Great voice big personality and brings a smile to all that see her!
Mnemosyne
23-03-2008
I like Francesca. I saw her in Rent and she was great. I also liked Nancy Nancy but obviously she's gone now.
Elanor
23-03-2008
The only one I can remember now is Cleopatra. I'll reserve judgement though.
princess sam
23-03-2008
JODIE PRENGER



yep she is hands down the best I hope she wins it. love her to bits... very talented and awesome personality...

GO JODIE... you got my vote sunshine... xx
MrSpielberg
23-03-2008
Jodie
hannahb39
23-03-2008
Well it would have been Nancy but as she has gone I think Jodie would make a good Nancy.

Will have to see them all properly though until I make a final decision.
lasity
23-03-2008
Originally Posted by hannahb39:
“Well it would have been Nancy but as she has gone I think Jodie would make a good Nancy.

Will have to see them all properly though until I make a final decision.”

Lets pick someone who will really do the part justice and in my opinion its Jodie from Blackpool!
bluejools
23-03-2008
would have been nancy nancy but im rooting for jessie now.
lasity
23-03-2008
Originally Posted by bluejools:
“would have been nancy nancy but im rooting for jessie now.”

The Olivers range from 9 -13 how can you have an Oliver at 13 and a Nancy at 17 ???????????
It wont work she has to at least be in her late 20's!
bluejools
24-03-2008
Originally Posted by lasity:
“The Olivers range from 9 -13 how can you have an Oliver at 13 and a Nancy at 17 ???????????
It wont work she has to at least be in her late 20's!”

i think jessie looks old enough to carry the part,if ALW didnt think she was good enough he wouldnt have put her through,shes amazing and perfect for nancy imho!
Glinny
24-03-2008
I love Jodie she is what Nancy is all about but unfortunately there is already a chosen one and that is FRANCESCA.
watch'n'waite
24-03-2008
I'd love to see Fran win but I can't agree that she is "the chosen one"

I think you'll find that some of the "professionals" only enter these things because they are given ultimatums by their agents.
fainnegeal
24-03-2008
Jessie is going to grow so much as this show progresses I know someone who saw her in school productions and Carolsel and they say she is the real deal and left them gobsmacked at the end of the performance, Shes a comet that only passes our way once in a life time.Congrats for spotting the fleeting glances weve got so far, voting might be stacked against her as cannot vote from Ireland.
playhousechick
24-03-2008
Originally Posted by lasity:
“The Olivers range from 9 -13 how can you have an Oliver at 13 and a Nancy at 17 ???????????
It wont work she has to at least be in her late 20's!”

But they are going on the character in the Dickens Novel where she is a 17/18 year old, so that is what they want. Admittedly she needs to be wise beyond her years.
MrSpielberg
24-03-2008
True Nancy was 17 in the original Dickens novel but that was when life expectancy was very short. Most died at 40 years old. By todays life spans Nancy would be in her 30's !
Starryeyes
24-03-2008
I see where you are coming from abotu Nancy's age- but unless they are updating the time period then surely thats a bit irrelevant? If we set it as Dicken's specified then Nancy is supposed to be 17, regardless of life expectancy now.

Of course, that doesn't mean we can't bend the boundaries a little!
whip
24-03-2008
Originally Posted by Starryeyes:
“I see where you are coming from abotu Nancy's age- but unless they are updating the time period then surely thats a bit irrelevant? If we set it as Dicken's specified then Nancy is supposed to be 17, regardless of life expectancy now.

Of course, that doesn't mean we can't bend the boundaries a little!”

If we are going by that standard he also wrote Oliver came from a workhouse and I don't see any of the Olivers having that background.
Starryeyes
25-03-2008
Originally Posted by whip:
“If we are going by that standard he also wrote Oliver came from a workhouse and I don't see any of the Olivers having that background.”



I though we were trying to find someone to 'act' the role?
I wasn't suggesting we find a Nancy with an abusive husband, just someone nearish the orginal age-range!
MrSpielberg
25-03-2008
The trouble is a 17 year old in Dickens time had been working most of her life and her life experience was far greater than the majority of 17 year olds today.
To get that experience which is valid to play the part you will need to go for an older girl and hence I see the younger ones below 20 not being able to pull it off,
twingle
25-03-2008
I have a few I liked but too early for me to throw in the cap with one. Anyway I am better not to say as whoever I back I jinx!!
Starryeyes
25-03-2008
Originally Posted by MrSpielberg:
“The trouble is a 17 year old in Dickens time had been working most of her life and her life experience was far greater than the majority of 17 year olds today.
To get that experience which is valid to play the part you will need to go for an older girl and hence I see the younger ones below 20 not being able to pull it off,”

OK, I see what you mean.
I still believe its about 'acting', but you have a valid point.

I should be agreeing with you anyway- i'm rooting for one of the older girls!!
Mark Boden
25-03-2008
It simply has to be Blackpool's Jodie. And whilst Im sure you'll all think I'm biased cause I live here, let me assure you I'm not - Jodie has the raw talent, larger than life, gusty personallity that both ALW and CM insist they are looking for.

And if you check the Bookies, Jodie is second from top at 6/1, with only the total professional, I've done this before, friends of DVO - Franceseca above her.

Public of Britain - Back Jodie From Blackpool - We've already lost the casino - We must win this one!

YOu Go All The Way Jodie - North Pier is right behind you!
lasity
25-03-2008
Originally Posted by Mark Boden:
“It simply has to be Blackpool's Jodie. And whilst Im sure you'll all think I'm biased cause I live here, let me assure you I'm not - Jodie has the raw talent, larger than life, gusty personallity that both ALW and CM insist they are looking for.

And if you check the Bookies, Jodie is second from top at 6/1, with only the total professional, I've done this before, friends of DVO - Franceseca above her.

Public of Britain - Back Jodie From Blackpool - We've already lost the casino - We must win this one!

YOu Go All The Way Jodie - North Pier is right behind you!”

I totally agree Jodie has everything it takes to be a great NANCY she gets my vote all the way.

Just out of interest where did you get those odds from? I have tried some of the well known betting sites and cant seem to find any odds on I'll Do Anything???
<<
<
2 of 5
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map