fair enough but thats not to say a boy with a lovely voice cant play oliver .

OMG! Don't kill a great song like this!

Should have done this one yesterday Amy

Yes, a little bit. I now actively like Jodie rather than just thinking she's OK.

Also think Niamh is hugely over-rated and am baffled as to how Amy got this far as her voice is so far removed from what a Nancy needs that I have no idea what the producers saw in her.

Francesa has so much more depth.

Amy starts the sing off song so badly, she should have walked after the first line! Francesca is singing this far better than her original song!!

Why do they announce who had the lowest public vote - surely not trying to influence judges

They're both lousy!

Where did I write that he couldn't play Oliver? I said he needs to lose the Welsh accent, which he will.

And Amy helps him further by singing off-key

Why did they announce who got the lowest public vote.. they never do that... and asking the panel who should go..... she was pretty mediocre but WTF did Amy do to merit this kind of assassination???

omg amys awful

Jeez can we just get rid of both of them!!!

I find it interesting, too..... but it seems cruel

Bye Amy!

Even more shrill to my Chita ears tonight.

Franceasca sounds better. I hope she doesn't suffer from her association with Denise Van Outen.

STOP! STOP! PLEASE STOP!

Murdering that song!

Only because it's on the BBC

No they've always done that, the girl that came second in Maria regularly had the least public votes.

I think Amy was awful. francesca wasn't much better but her training showed through.

OK ... so for Maria we had the trauma of So Long Farewell
And for the Holy Joe's we had Close every door...

What the schnuff are these girls gonna say their goodbyes...

And for my money ... Amy goes, Fran should stay - that was beautifully measured by her... and soooo cruel the irony ... Tell me on a Sunday...

That was absolutely terrible from Amy. Screechy and tuneless.

Francesca wasn't great but deserves to live to fight another day.

They always have done this on Maria/Joespeh

Francesca was the better by far there.

I've hear better singers busking....

Amy - ouch! That really was cringeworthy.

My fiver is on Jodie to win.