Who do you think should go?

Ashley
Cleo
Jessie
Jodie
Keisha
Niamh
Rachel
Samantha
Sarah
Tara

I think Keisha this week

I think Keisha this week - I didn't like the performance at all.

I'd say Tara.

Keisha was bad, but Tara has been weak both weeks.

Tara or Ashley, Keisha and Jodie can be better, Cleo might get better.

I agree with the general consenus that Keisha and Tara are clearly the weakest. Everyone else may disagree but Ashley really grates me. Though she was better this week so I wouldn't chuck her out just yet.

Rachel or Niamh

I would like these two to leave, never a Nancy either of them.

Based on tonight Keisha which would be a shame as she was one of the better ones last week.

Keisha

Ashley, Tara or Keisha. Don't really mind which one.

Totally agree

keisha or tara

Well, I agree that Keisha and Tara were the poorest. I also agree that Keisha did beautifully last week. Both of them had awful songs chosen for them (well, Without You isn't an awful song, but you know what I mean) so it seems unfair to say it, but Tara, it's time to head back to Wales...

I thought Keisha was dreadful both weeks. I think she should possibly go even ahead of Tara.

Tara or Keisha. Not keen on Ashley either but she was better than those two, IMO

Keisha was rather dire tonight.
Easily the worst by a mile.

I agree about Keisha and Tara giving the poorest performances - I wonder whether they were deliberately given those songs to 'test' them? Tara especially - that song will really show whether you can cut it or not.

Ashley's performance was better but it seemed a bit vacant and emotion-less. The choreography was a bit rubbish too but that's obviously not her fault.

I also thought Niamh's performance was nowhere near as good as the panel was suggesting - she seemed to shout quite a lot of it. It's also not the most memorable song and she could suffer from going first?

But then I was totally wrong about the bottom 2 last week

It pains me to say it because I like her but Cleo, out of all of them she's the least there, the weaker perfomer's last week all upped there game massively except for her.

Niamh or Tara

The one I woould pick you appear to have left off the list Francesca - not keen on her at all - for performance only tho my vote would be Keisha

Agreed.
Keisha wasn't very strong this week, but she gave such a good performance last week she deserves another chance.

Am I the only one who can see how awful Cleopatra is in comparison with the others? Same goes for Tara, but other people seem to notice how sub-par she is.

I missed Niamh's performance, but from the few seconds I saw of it in the recap it sounded kinda bad.

I really hope Keisha stays. She was 100% fabulous last week and deserves to be in the competition. She's also a fellow English student! GO KEISHA.

Tara/ Keisha /Cleo

No, but there is something about Cleo that is very likeable.


I agree.

Neeve (can't be bothered to check the spelling,sorry)
Totally unsuitable for the part, though Lloyd Webber seems to like her.