I find Cleo unwatchable. She just looks very uncomfortable. She's the opposite of Rachel, who appears over-comfortable.

Niamh...she just doesn't have the stage presence for the part. And I couldn't understand the judges' glowing comments, I thought vocally she was pretty weak again tonight.

I totally agree, I think they wil be the bottom two.
Keisha I think had a bad song to sing and she did what she could with it, but it was not great, but last week she was the absolute strongest for me,
where as Tara was awful last week and this week although a lot better, was still no where near good enough, the song was way too big for her and the very loud BV's overshadowed the fact that she was struggling as much as she was, also I find the faces she makes also quite odd. Her head voice is lovely but as soon as she has to sing anything with a bit of welly she seems to struggle. i hope it is her that goes. Francesca was soooooooooo much better too.

With regard to Tara, I think that's exactly what they did. Not with Keisha, though. Although I think she had great songs both weeks and murdered both, they seemed to like her last week, so I can't see that they would deliberately give her an unsuitable song to test her. She just isn't as good as they thought she was.

That horrible flat 'sulky teenager' hairstyle annoys me.
She looked so much better (and more likeable) in her VT.

I havent yet warmed to any of these people yet so I'll say either:

Ashley
Keisha
Tara

Jodie or Francesca

Taking everything into consideration, I'd say Cleo. She's been very close to the bottom for me for two weeks in a row.

Keisha was terrible this week (the worst) but I loved her performance last week, so I'm cutting her some slack.

Tara was appalling last week but improved a lot this week. She's still not brilliant and she'll never be Nancy but based on tonight's performance she probably deserves another shot.

Tara or Keisha for me.

Another votes for Tara or Keisha.....But who knows!

I can't bear Niamh, her voice is dreadful, really piercing, I don't understand why the judges praise her so much.
Ashley, Francesca & Samantha too irritate me.
Keisha is too 'I love myself.'

It wont happen but I would Love ALW to have to choose between Francesca and Rachel to who goes, The show would be better without the HAM sandwiches

Deleted
Last edited by pinkfish : 06-04-2008 at 14:06

Tara. She can't sing in tune so for me it's a no brainer.

Totally agree with that comment

If Tara is in the bottom two, which is not unlikely, she will definitely go. It seems clear to me that they deliberately gave her a song that was 'too big for her'. Why give such a difficult song to a singer who can't cope with it, if not to show up her inadequacies? Somebody has to go out tonight, and they evidently regard Tara as expendable.

Tara. Has to be.

Yep, agreed, Tara wasn't good on either occasion.

tara has been consistantly bad, even though keisha was bad she would get saved in a sing-off against tara
it will probably be one of those two