Originally Posted by Mulett:
“But it also got the second lowest AI of season 9, only beaten by Sleep No More.
I personally think it was more of a 'Marmite' episode than the newspaper reviews/comments on here would have us believe. Certainly not the sort of episode I think would coax back the 1.5m who've switched off although I think, within fan circles, it will be called a classic.
But then, speaking as a fan, I am sometimes a little bemused by what gets labeled a classic by fans. Caves of Androzani is (for me) only exceptional because its a regeneration story. Beyond that, pretty bland. But Doctor Who Magazine readers voted it the best story ever.”
My original comments were about over 55s, who clearly hated it according to the AI scores, and it was their score of 76 that was the reason why it finished with the second lowest AI of S9. The 16-34s gave it a score 9 higher!
I suspect that such an episode would attract many NEW viewers to the show if they were made to watch it, with its adult themes of inner torment and the incredible performance by Peter, it's as far away from "kids TV" as the show is likely to ever go