I think tonight proves what I said in my other thread - though Keisha's difficult song choice pinned her up as favourite to go this week, she absolutely shone in the head-to-head sing-off. So glad she's still in it.

As for Cleopatra - lovely as she is, she just wasn't right. The sing-off proved that her voice wasn't ripe enough - she often sounded strained and waily, and sometimes a little off-key. I don't think she's quite ready yet.

Although, I still think Tara should have gone before her.

I did love Cleo and didnt really love Keisha but i see what you mean. On the basis of the sing-off itself, Keisha should have stayed but on last night's performance, it should have been Cleo. I'm undecided as to whether it was the right or wrong decision.

In my opinion, Tara should have been out because I feel that she is the weakest in the competition. And should not have even got through to the live shows.

I agree with both the above comments, I did not want either of them to go, but I would say I would have considered Cleo the more likely Nancy, but Keisha outsang her in the sing off, but it should have been TARA to go.

Why is she still there.... well I know why, because people are voting for her, but I dont get why, unless its just a Welsh vote, if it is, I wish they would just give it to Sarah or Fran.

I don't think Cleopatra should have been in the bottom two (oh, and just a question, at what point did the programme start dropping the "patra" part of her name?!), but as others have said, once she was, Keisha performed much better in the sing-off, so I think it was the right decision.

I also was left pretty unimpressed by Cleo's As Long As He Needs Me...

Tara has got the NORTH Welsh vote behind her, and they can be a very tribal lot, and having El Bandito and the wrestling fraternity behind her will help a lot too!

South Wales splits its votes between Fran and Sarah

Keisha was loads better in the sing-off and Cleo was weak. Wish they'd tone down Keisha's eye-shadow though!!