• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • I'd Do Anything
Girls you think are definitely NOT Nancy
<<
<
1 of 4
>>
>
Futuring
06-04-2008
We hear every week from ALW how everyone has a different image of who Nancy could be, but based both on what we've seen so far (which is liable to alteration) and even perhaps on what they look like, who do you really think doesn't fit the role...at all?

For me it would be:

Ashley
Tara

And perhaps Sara. I'm still not sure about her.
Ignazio
06-04-2008
At the moment I can only see three Nancy's; Jessie, Fran and Jodie.

So no the rest of them.
Mark Boden
06-04-2008
Sorry Ladies,

But for me deff not Tara, then Ashley

Ashley I see as Truely Scrumptuious in Chitty
Tara I see as the Una Stubbs character in Summer Holiday (If it's still touring)

But then you may all think I'm mad.
Aleksis
06-04-2008
Tara, Samantha, Niamh, Ashley are definitely not Nancy.

Ideally I'd want Jodie or Keisha. Jessie is fabulous, but she's a little bit young and fresh-faced.
thenetworkbabe
06-04-2008
Keisha. Probably Tara. Probably Jodie though I can see why she might look like an older Nancy for some people.

Ashley is looking better though the singing may not be Nancy. Niamh we need to see acting.
Ashrell
06-04-2008
Tara - she's not a good singer and she doesn't really suit the image.

Niamh - she's great, but I think she's a bit too young, too fragile etc.
lipgloss
06-04-2008
All of them.

Just dont see a nancy at all.

Perhaps I just have no idea what I'm looking for.
LaurieMarlow
06-04-2008
Not Nancy - Tara, Ashley, Niamh (just doesn't have the maturity and emotional depth).

I'm not sure about Keisha, she might be able to, I need to see more of her.

I can see Jessie, Jodie, Rachel, Francesca, Sam and Sarah in the part. They would all be very different Nancys, but I think they could pull it off.
cazzbar
06-04-2008
In my mind I see Jodie as Nancy, possibly Jessie or Fran too - but not quite as much.

That could change over the next few weeks though as we hear and see more of the girls.
Pete Callan
06-04-2008
Not Nancy - Ashley, Tara, Keisha, Niamh and Samantha

Jodie, Francesca and Rachel are the main contenders in my mind.
CaroUK
07-04-2008
Definitely NOT Nancy are Ashley, Tara (both too meh! for the role), Sarah (looks way too young fresh and innocent), Francesca (speech and diction problems)and Niamh (really don't see why she is there at all

Could be Nancys are Jodie (tart with a heart and big voice), Rachel (seems to be a good all rounder and I can see why Fran was her understudy), Jessie (seems to have it all at the moment but needs every minute of her time in the Nancy house to pull it off) and Keisha.
acertree
07-04-2008
Not nancy:

Tara, Samantha, Niamh, Jessie, Keisha, Ashely

Nancy
Sarah, Jodie, Rachel, Franchesca,

- Rachel and Sarah are the best actreses out of my final 4. Jodie was poor in the acting scenes.
gillypanda
07-04-2008
Tara, Ashley, Keisha, Rachel, Niamh, Samantha

I still like Jessie and Jodie, but Francesca has grown on me too, and Sarah I'm just not sure.
hannahb39
07-04-2008
Tara, Ashley, Jessie, Keisha and Niamh are not my Nancy.

The only ones I really like so far are Sarah, Jodie and Francesca.
spider9
07-04-2008
Niamh,

and Jodie

*hides*
Tortue
07-04-2008
Originally Posted by spider9:
“Niamh,

and Jodie

*hides*”


You're brave

Personally I think she's awful. And her acting
spider9
07-04-2008
Originally Posted by Tortue:
“You're brave

Personally I think she's awful. And her acting ”

come and hide with me then!
GirlfromEireann
07-04-2008
Originally Posted by spider9:
“come and hide with me then!”

Can I go into hiding with you both aswell.

Jodie's a nice person, but I can't see her as being Nancy. Her acting was too forced.

Also, I can't see Keisha - she's too theatre, which I know is a strange thing to say, but Nancy isn't Maria von Trapp.
kyri
07-04-2008
Tara. She's terrible, it's beyond me why she is still there.
threecheeses
07-04-2008
Jodie - love her but she looks too old for the part for me, especially if they get some Hollyoaks type Sykes in.

Keisha - same as above.

Rachel, Niamh, Tara, Ashley, Francesca - just wouldn't care if Sykes bumped them off (and you should)

Sarah - far too Kitty in my pocket to play her.

Which for me leaves Jessie and Samantha as Nancy
mikkey
07-04-2008
Am I missing something here but why does everyone love Jodie?? she is as false as they come and Nancy is supposed to be a soulful, homebird.
Starryeyes
07-04-2008
Niamh, Keisha, Tara, Jessie and Sam are 100% not Nancy

Jodie is probably not Nancy but she could convince me.

Ashley, Rachel, Sarah and Fran could all be Nancy.
mikkey
07-04-2008
Originally Posted by Tortue:
“You're brave

Personally I think she's awful. And her acting ”

Thank god you agree! and that stunt with the boyfriend - whats that all about??
Murraymar
07-04-2008
Originally Posted by mikkey:
“Thank god you agree! and that stunt with the boyfriend - whats that all about??”

Puts hands up. she's a bit too brassy for my liking
zankoku87
07-04-2008
I don't see the appeal with Ashley and Tara, personally. Niamh's a talented enough singer but I really cannot see her in the role. While I can see they're both very talented, there's something about Rachel and Jessie that I don't really like in their performances. Samantha's just a bit dull! Any of the others are fine as far as I'm concerned.
<<
<
1 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map