I agree with ALW that she might not have chosen the best song but I thought she delivered it pretty well. I actually thought Niamh did the best job at selling her song this week and although I still have some reservations about her voice I thought she stood out, and yet she got slaughtered even more than Jessie did.
DVO and JB are increasingly defying credibilty. Jodie seemed to sleepwalk her way through her vocal which I put down to her trying to concentrate on her movement as well, and yet her movement was embarrassing. Yet is was Jessie's vocal criticised as vanilla and her movement called not very feminine. Rachel was weak and her croaking 'luv' followed by a posh 'yoo-oo-oo' was quite funny but escaped censure. Sam was all over the place and the worst of the night (yet again) but was praised to the skies.
Sam should be in the sing-off, and I think probably Rachel should join her, though Jodie should have no complaints. However I fear that if the judges comments sway voters there is a danger of it being Niamh and Jessie.
As something of a postscript, I have to say I rather liked Jessie with her hair straighter, as could be seen in the video clips of the week.
Last edited by grunson : 17-05-2008 at 22:11