Should they give Rachel a new look?

2 of 2

piper333

03-05-2008

Originally Posted by PenguinBear:
“I think she is getting votes simply because people see her as the professional and the most technically sound with the smallest amount of errors or criticism from the panel.

It's a difficult situation if ALW actually really doesn't like her because, Rachel is obviously pretty talented based on her experience and training. It's pretty hard to say, well you have a good voice and everything but I just don't like you.”

Fran was pro too, with a role in Rent which was a bigger play than Tonight's the Night imo. didn't work for her.

PenguinBear

03-05-2008

Originally Posted by piper333:
“Fran was pro too, with a role in Rent which was a bigger play than Tonight's the Night imo. didn't work for her.”

Well that was the problem. The media and show focussed so much on Fran's expereince and connection to DVO that it hurt her. They really havent' as much with Rachel, so Rachel has been able to avoid any negativity on that front.

piper333

03-05-2008

Originally Posted by PenguinBear:
“Well that was the problem. The media and show focussed so much on Fran's expereince and connection to DVO that it hurt her. They really havent' as much with Rachel, so Rachel has been able to avoid any negativity on that front.”

I agree, but i never forgot that Rachel said Fran was her understudy... stuck like glue in my brain. lol

CASPER1066

03-05-2008

You must want the part really bad if you'd sleep with AWL.as Rachel is supposed to have said.........."hands on ears".....screaming loudly...eeeeeekkkkkkkkkkkk

Satchmo

04-05-2008

Originally Posted by CASPER1066:
“You must want the part really bad if you'd sleep with AWL.as Rachel is supposed to have said.........."hands on ears".....screaming loudly...eeeeeekkkkkkkkkkkk”

Has it crossed your mind that maybe that was said as a joke?

Jesus, every post of yours I come across manages to make some dig at Rachel regardless of whether the thread's even about her. OK, she's not everyone's cup of tea but cut the girl some slack

CASPER1066

04-05-2008

[

Quote:
“QUOTE=Satchmo;23448915]Has it crossed your mind that maybe that was said as a joke?

Jesus, every post of yours I come across manages to make some dig at Rachel regardless of whether the thread's even about her. OK, she's not everyone's cup of tea but cut the girl some slack”

[/quote]

thanks for you interaction......however it is my opinion that she should not be in the competition...she sings out of tune and forgets her lines.......her voice cracks.....and she is supposed to be the professional....and guess what..... maybe it wasnt a joke....

.

In my opinion

Satchmo

04-05-2008

Originally Posted by CASPER1066:
“thanks for you interaction......however it is my opinion that she should not be in the competition...she sings out of tune and forgets her lines.......her voice cracks.....and she is supposed to be the professional....and guess what..... maybe it wasnt a joke.....

In my opinion”

Want to try being a little more patronising?

If she shouldn't be in the competition then you can rule out Sam, Niamh and Ashley on exactly the same basis but they seem to escape your constant criticism

Try watching her singing The Way We Were and tell me just where she's out of tune on that

rolacola1987

04-05-2008

I don't mean to sound cruel or bitchy, and I am starting to like rachel, but she does something with her mouth which i can't explain that reminds me of the grinch

bunnykin

04-05-2008

Originally Posted by LaurieMarlow:
“If they do want her to win and they need viewers to warm to her, they should stage a 'crisis of confidence' and have a VT in which she cries and tells the audience that it's always been her dream to make it in musical theatre and she fears this is her last chance and she doesn't know what she's going to do if she can't make her dreams come true, it will devastate her, blah, blah, blah.”

Heh heh. They did show us her 'tears' tonight when they showed the VT her after she'd sung one of ALW's songs for ALW himself which she, apparently, just found so "overwhelming". Fortunately, IMO, they showed it well after the voting lines had closed as I don't think her show of emotion will have done her any favours (well not if I had been considering voting for her, which of course I wasn't

PenguinBear

04-05-2008

Originally Posted by rolacola1987:
“I don't mean to sound cruel or bitchy, and I am starting to like rachel, but she does something with her mouth which i can't explain that reminds me of the grinch”

LOL. Yes come to think of it she does look like the Grinch.

She is just unlikeable for kids, she would be better off in adult roles or as a temptress.

Norti

04-05-2008

Rachel's face is wonky as she admitted in one of her vt's, and there's nothing she can do about it. But it doesn't help being seen singing close up on TV and but the problem is with the viewers if they don't like her for it.

2 of 2