Worst song - who got the worst song this week, i think Jodie or Sarah got the worst songs given to them this week.

Best song - Suprise Suprise Sam got given the best song again.

Worst Dress - Niamh - looked like she had a silk sheet wrapped around her.Ashleys was awful too.

Best Dress - Rachel or Sarah - both nice.

Best vocal - Sarah and Jessie

Worst vocal - Sam and Ashley

best performance - Jodie and jessie.

Worst performance - Ashley

Vocally

Thought Rachel was pants

Sarah was poor (and I usually like her)

Jodie ok
Naimh ok

Sam good
Ashley Good

Jessie, have to listen again not sure!

Best Ashley
Wors Sam

Worst song - Jodie and Sarah definitely

Best song - Sam

Worst Dress - Ashleys!

Best Dress - I actually though Niamh looked nice in her dress

Best vocal - Jessie and Niamh

Worst vocal - Ashley

best performance - Jessie

Worst performance - Ashley

seriously - ashley, best, come on! your having a laugh!

Best: Jessie - gave me chills
Worst: Sam - i just didn't feel it lived up to the hype

Worst vocal and performance- Rachel
Best performance- Jessie
Not sure-niamh

No Im not, funnilyenough

Best performance - Jessie
Worst - Niamh but Ashley was a bit bizarre

Worst song choices - Jodie and Sarah (poor lasses)

Worst dress - Jodie - floor-length satin on a buxom lass, I don't think so :sleep:

Jessie magic, Jodie pants.

I know you like her - but surely thats biased beyond belief to say she was the best!!

I've gotta say (argh Sorry Jodie) everyone but Jessie has faded from memory already.

Jessie's performance was truely outstanding.

And can Niamh stop the crazy arm waving thing please.

Rachel was the worst tonight, Imo she was crap I just dont see what the panel see
Why they say she's the one to beat puzzels me

Jessie the best by a long shot, I dont usually like her as I think she overacts but she sang the judy song perfectly

Yeah it probably is, but;

Rachel & Samantha werent very good were they?
Jodie was good, as was Jessie
Niamh was okay, but dull.
Sarah wasnt at her best but still good, but I preferred Ashley's better, because I think she gave us something different, as she always does, which is why I like her

yep I agree with all three

What I find interesting is how many of us thought that Sarah and Jodie were stitched up with the song choices. Do they really think we're that stupid? The days of manipulating the audience have long gone. We're all to realty show savvy to fall for what they're trying to do. Hopefully because of their past performances both girls will go through and ALW can throw another tantrum because two of his faves are in the bottom two.

Best - Jessie
Worst - Rachel/Niamh

She gave something different but bad! Rachel and sam were bad, Niamh not greta, sarah i love, but wasn't her best week. Jodie i like alot, and thought she did well tonight, Jessie was awsome, and i don't normally rate her highly.

Sarah and Jodie were stitched up with their songs - i felt bad for them, yet even with their terribly bad song choices given to them, they still did better than sam, who, as usual was given the best song.

Best vocal - Niamh

Worst vocal - Ashley

Best performance - Sam

Worst performance - Jodie

But it wasn;t bad? In my opinion it was good, she put herself into a character, and tbh the accent made me enjoy it even more. Shes taken the most risks in this show, and has nothing to lose, shes doing her best (as is everyone), and I thought it spayed off.

ash ftw

Can i ask - what accent was she trying to do? she just made her voice sould weird and bad.

LOL I dunno but I likedi t. I dont see you questioning everybody else on their opinions? You asked who I thought was my favourite and I told you =\

I was just suprised anyone could say ashley was the best, putting her near the top of your list if you like her in general i understand, but her performance was so bad tonight, and others were good, just no way she was the best. thats why. Like last week, there is no way anyone could say Niamh was the best, as she was terribly bad!

Tbh comparing Ashleys this week to Niamh last week is unfair, Ashley wasn't really "bad" She hit all the notes etc unlike Niamh

She did hit the notes ok yes, but that weird accent thing she was doing was awful, and it was the performance that was as bad as niamhs vocals last week.