This weeks blog is available

http://blogs.thestage.co.uk/tvtoday/...deo/index.html

I do enjoy reading his take on the programme.
Last edited by Tissy : 06-05-2008 at 14:03

i gave the same critique on ashley on Sunday.

i agree with most of what he says all around.

I am glad Scott Matheson enjoyed Ashleys performance and explained the reason for the accent (original Fosse choreography). It would have been good if ALW had explained to the viewers why he had directed her to do the accent in the first place instead of leaving her, yet again, wide opened to criticism - but then - why would he?
Regardless I loved it and felt she deserved my vote

I think it was a fair summary

I love reading his reviews. Generally I agree with him.

Well, that's no fun, is it?

Seriously, thanks to everyone for the support.

Out of interest, who do you want to win?

Honestly, I have no idea. I think right now that any of the remaining six could do the job. I still have reservations about Jessie's acting when she's not singing, but if she works really hard between now and December when previews start she could fix those problems, which are mainly down to inexperience and anxiety.

Love your blog. Great to read a considered response that's not pandering to some of the siller things said by the panel.

It is never fun we people are so cruel for the sake of it. That is what I like about your summaries (although I don’t always agree with them 100%) they are objectively fair.

Agree with it I suppose except Samantha, IMO she didnt sing and dance well, her singing was abysmal.

Thank you Scott for your weekly reviews. I wait for it every week, even though I don't always agree!

Love it, Scott, love your description of Ashley's movement... spot on

This weeks blog from Mr Matthewman

http://blogs.thestage.co.uk/tvtoday/...k-9/index.html

These reviews seem to be written by someone who actually watches the same show as me!!!!

great review

Very fair.

I totally agree with that! Maybe Scott could be on the panel next time, as he seems to hear what the rest of us hear each week!

That's quite a good idea! He would be a better replacement for Zoe than BH or any other celeb.

Oh God no. I have what they call 'a face for radio'.

Come to that, I also have a voice for print.

Well, BH is no oil painting LOL!

Any links for Zoe's column in The Stage?

I think her column is in the print version of the paper only.

I think you're right. I wondered how her comments compared to the panel's comments.

Someone who is positive about niamh - that makes a change