Originally Posted by brangdon:
“She's not deliberately undermining or sabotaging. She's not tactful with her advice, but I think she'd have won more if her project leaders had listened to her. Generally what she says makes sense: had Sara listened about the English food she might not have had to cancel lunch; had Simon listened about the production issues they might have got some photos printed and sold; had Kevin listened about who should do the pitch they might have won the card task; had Raef listened about getting shots of the box they might have won the advert task.
Her teams have lost despite her rather than because of her. When she is the leader herself, she wins.”
“She's not deliberately undermining or sabotaging. She's not tactful with her advice, but I think she'd have won more if her project leaders had listened to her. Generally what she says makes sense: had Sara listened about the English food she might not have had to cancel lunch; had Simon listened about the production issues they might have got some photos printed and sold; had Kevin listened about who should do the pitch they might have won the card task; had Raef listened about getting shots of the box they might have won the advert task.
Her teams have lost despite her rather than because of her. When she is the leader herself, she wins.”
I don't think kevin would have won because the idea was flawed. I don't think that Raef would have won the task if they included the shots. They all missed the point of the tissues being antibacterial even Claire. She was good at the pitch but her performance was poor in the last task being the most experienced in marketing out f the seven candidates. I don't think that Sara would have listened to Claire even if she knew that Claire was right. Sara said in post-firing interviews that she is a strict Muslim. She would not have been able to cook some of the elements of the english breakfast.
However, I agree with your main point. Claire is often right. Less mistakes would have been made, had PMs listened to her advice.




