Jodie by miles, but if I've got to pick a 2nd, then Sam. I prefer Jessie's voice to Sam's but she can't act, dance or move, imo. Rachel just seems to pass me by.
ARe you either a Rachel/Jodie supporter or a Sam/Jessie fan?
3 of 3
Jodie is by far the best Nancy.
Jessie needs more training good voice but nothing else.
Sam - tuneless, vacant expressions while singing, cant act.
Rachel - cold, not popular with the public, can act, singing inconsistant
Jessie needs more training good voice but nothing else.
Sam - tuneless, vacant expressions while singing, cant act.
Rachel - cold, not popular with the public, can act, singing inconsistant
I do kinda agree my favourite has always been Jessie but Sam just stood out by a mile last week, with Jessie becoming "inconsistent" i am starting to think she is the best...
I cant warm to Rachel at all and Jodie does seem to have got worse as the weeks go by...
I cant warm to Rachel at all and Jodie does seem to have got worse as the weeks go by...
Not really.
Sam and Rachel: I didn't like either of them are the beginning, but they are both growing on me and at the moment, my two favourites (although to be honest, it's more like 2 I am least apathetic to)
Jessie: Was one of my favourites at the beginning, but I am slowly losing interest in her
Jodie: Has been consistent, but fails to interest me
Sam and Rachel: I didn't like either of them are the beginning, but they are both growing on me and at the moment, my two favourites (although to be honest, it's more like 2 I am least apathetic to)
Jessie: Was one of my favourites at the beginning, but I am slowly losing interest in her
Jodie: Has been consistent, but fails to interest me
I'm a Jodie supporter 
think she's great and would be perfect as Nancy.
Don't like Jessie, she has irritated me throughout the competition.
Rachel and Sam I have liked on and off. Sam can dance and thought last week she sang brilliantly, was her best song by far, but she doesn't show any emotion in her face, it's blank and stony all the time. Rachel is consistent and can sing and act but is too polished, Nancy is rough around the edges and a little frayed, I don't think that's Rachel.
think she's great and would be perfect as Nancy.Don't like Jessie, she has irritated me throughout the competition.
Rachel and Sam I have liked on and off. Sam can dance and thought last week she sang brilliantly, was her best song by far, but she doesn't show any emotion in her face, it's blank and stony all the time. Rachel is consistent and can sing and act but is too polished, Nancy is rough around the edges and a little frayed, I don't think that's Rachel.
I like Rachel and Sam best, wouldn't mind Jodie. Like Jessie's voice but really don't think she is up to the acting skills required for Nancy.
Going for the youngsters to win.
I think that's the way the wind is blowing.
Jessie was put down last week. Watch this week as she gets told she has risen to the challenge and could be Nancy!
And the public gets what the public wants....
I think that's the way the wind is blowing.
Jessie was put down last week. Watch this week as she gets told she has risen to the challenge and could be Nancy!
And the public gets what the public wants....
Definately a Jodie/Rachel supporter. I think Jodie is the most suited but I prefer Rachel's voice for the part.
Jessie is getting better each week and I don't mind her gawky dancing at all. But Sam seems like she is more suited to other musicals leading lady parts. She needs to stop wearing such tight clothes because they make her look too young to be Nancy.
Jessie is getting better each week and I don't mind her gawky dancing at all. But Sam seems like she is more suited to other musicals leading lady parts. She needs to stop wearing such tight clothes because they make her look too young to be Nancy.
I'd be happy enough with Jodie, Rachel or Sam.
Jodie is consistent with a lovely voice and personifies my image of the "tart with a heart" Nancy.
Rachel is also consistent and i think has a better voice than Jodie. She doesn't capture me in the same way personality wise but i think she'd be a surprisingly great Nancy.
Samantha i think is extremely talented for a 17 year old but i'm not convinced she has the necessary experience for the WE stage night after night. Give her a few years and she could potentially be phenomenal.
The only one i don't particularly like is Jessie for a dozen reasons that are talked about all over the forum so don't really need to be said again.
Jodie is consistent with a lovely voice and personifies my image of the "tart with a heart" Nancy.
Rachel is also consistent and i think has a better voice than Jodie. She doesn't capture me in the same way personality wise but i think she'd be a surprisingly great Nancy.
Samantha i think is extremely talented for a 17 year old but i'm not convinced she has the necessary experience for the WE stage night after night. Give her a few years and she could potentially be phenomenal.
The only one i don't particularly like is Jessie for a dozen reasons that are talked about all over the forum so don't really need to be said again.
3 of 3
