• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • I'd Do Anything
Results:POLL: The Final - Who should be Nancy
Jodie
471 (55.81%)
Samantha
161 (19.08%)
Jessie
212 (25.12%)
Voters: 844. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
POLL: The Final - Who should be Nancy
<<
<
6 of 9
>>
>
eponine121
27-05-2008
Jodie
DavetheScot
28-05-2008
Sam for me.
stanlina
28-05-2008
Jodie
Red Lady
28-05-2008
Jodie
liverpool.lass
28-05-2008
I voted for Jodie but I also like Jessie. So if either of them win I will be happy. I think I would go for Jodie as Jessie is still young and has time to win other roles.
Evilredzebra
28-05-2008
Has to be Jodie. I don't think she is perfect by a long shot but compared to the competition she is the only choice. Jessie can't act or move and shows emotion in her singing by shouting. Sam is just dreadful all round.
Pimms
28-05-2008
Sam.
Despite protestations some may make, I believe many assessments here made of the alleged merits and capability of finalists are jaundiced and far from impartial. Seizing on any flaw (real or imagined) and using it as a justification for rejecting a different contender, while turning a blind eye to their own favorite's shortcomings. It is easy to do.

I admit my own choice is based on knowing Sam, and that the other two are also capable of being cast in the role. I didn't like the shouting-to-emote Sam did at JB's prompting a few weeks ago, but haven't seen this in later weeks; I thought Jodie's "Send in the Clowns" was great, and Jessie's "Man that got away" was too. Nevertheless they also have flaws and Sam is my favourite.

If this poll is an accurate reflection of opinion of people likely to vote on Saturday then it appears that Jodie will win the popular vote.
RichmondBlue
28-05-2008
Originally Posted by Evilredzebra:
“Has to be Jodie. I don't think she is perfect by a long shot but compared to the competition she is the only choice. Jessie can't act or move and shows emotion in her singing by shouting. Sam is just dreadful all round.”

Thats a bit unfair. We have not seen enough of any of them acting to judge their true ability.
From the bits we did see, Rachel seemed to have most acting ability...not much to choose between Jodie and Jessie with Sam some way behind. I dont think either Jessie or Jodie are particularly good " movers "...Sam would have to be the choice if that is really important to the role, which I dont think it is ?
I wish the BBC had given more air-time to show their acting capabilities, from what I have read elsewhere it is more important to the role this time.
I am going for Jessie..purely because she is physically closer to my own idea of the original Nancy.
CASPER1066
28-05-2008
Jodie
supergirlblibs
28-05-2008
Sam!!!!
RichmondBlue
28-05-2008
More importantly...who is going to play Bullseye ? ( Bill Sykes dog )
dml_30
28-05-2008
At the start of the series I thought that vocally Sam was the weakest but every week I think she improves.

That said, I think that Jodie would be better suited for the role.

Jessie? I hate to say this but there is something about her that annoys me and I can't quite think what.
Sorry, no being mean, just my opinion.
dudeuk87
28-05-2008
Jodie
Radio12
28-05-2008
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamantha
bluepenguin
28-05-2008
Jodie

or Jessie
ESPIONdansant
28-05-2008
Sam if she can glum up a bit and not smile all the time.
Starlet
29-05-2008
I don't watch the show, but remember Jodie from when she was on The Biggest Loser and thought she was lovely, so pleased to see she's still in the comp and well liked. Go Jodie.
LaurieMarlow
29-05-2008
Originally Posted by Pimms:
“Sam.
Despite protestations some may make, I believe many assessments here made of the alleged merits and capability of finalists are jaundiced and far from impartial. Seizing on any flaw (real or imagined) and using it as a justification for rejecting a different contender, while turning a blind eye to their own favorite's shortcomings. It is easy to do.

I admit my own choice is based on knowing Sam, and that the other two are also capable of being cast in the role. I didn't like the shouting-to-emote Sam did at JB's prompting a few weeks ago, but haven't seen this in later weeks; I thought Jodie's "Send in the Clowns" was great, and Jessie's "Man that got away" was too. Nevertheless they also have flaws and Sam is my favourite.

If this poll is an accurate reflection of opinion of people likely to vote on Saturday then it appears that Jodie will win the popular vote. ”

Well, obviously there's a certain amount of that going on with everyone. But what makes you think you're any different? You've just admitted that you know Sam, surely that has the potential to make you more biased than most?
rivka
29-05-2008
! Jodie
2 Jessie
3 Samantha
supergirlblibs
29-05-2008
Close betweeen Jessie and Sam!! Will be exciting!
Stephanie2007
29-05-2008
Jodie
Jessie
Samantha

Jodie to win! I think she would make the best overall Nancy
insanitygonemad
29-05-2008
probably jodie, but im not really that bothered. i would have been if rachel was still in.
XxLiannexX
29-05-2008
Jodie/Jessie
TotalShopaholic
29-05-2008
Jodie. She is the only one out of the three that is ready for the role. Sam and Jessie both need to go back to a drama school to hone their skills. And of course Jessie needs stage movement/dance classes to eliminate her gawky weird movements.
Tangledweb7
29-05-2008
Originally Posted by Radio12:
“SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamanthaSamantha
SamanthaSamantha”

One word JESSIE a little says alot.
<<
<
6 of 9
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map